NBA Trade Verdict

Bucks Win

The Nets acquired Jianlian Yi; Bobby Simmons from Bucks in exchange for Richard Jefferson.

June 26, 2008 Brooklyn Nets / Milwaukee Bucks Record confidence: High

Trade Analysis

Milwaukee Paid Two Players for Richard Jefferson

On June 26, 2008, Milwaukee acquired established scoring forward Richard Jefferson from New Jersey for young Chinese forward Yi Jianlian and veteran Bobby Simmons. The deal came as the Bucks looked to create a more competitive perimeter pairing around Michael Redd and improve an offense that needed additional shot creation. New Jersey was rebuilding after trading Jason Kidd earlier that year and accepted a promising second-year player along with a wing whose contract could help balance the exchange. The historical Nets and Bucks transaction ledgers agree on the two-for-one terms and draft-night timing. No first-round pick was included in this specific agreement, so the two incoming Nets players must account for the direct return.

Jefferson Scored Nearly Twenty Points in Milwaukee

Jefferson started all 82 Bucks games in 2008-09 and averaged 19.6 points, 4.6 rebounds and 2.4 assists. The combination gave Milwaukee a reliable wing scorer for an entire season even though the Bucks failed to reach the postseason. Jefferson shot 39.7 percent from three and offered a veteran counterweight to the club’s established guards. He moved to San Antonio in June 2009, a separate transaction, so Milwaukee did not receive multiple Jefferson years. Its B+ grade reflects a full season of substantial offense from a player with a proven record, instead of pretending that the move secured a lasting playoff contender. The immediate scoring return was higher than either new Nets player provided that season.

Yi and Simmons Had More Limited Nets Contributions

Yi played 61 New Jersey games in 2008-09, starting 52 and averaging 8.6 points and 5.3 rebounds. He showed potential at power forward but did not develop into the franchise’s new leading scorer. Simmons added veteran perimeter minutes and contract flexibility, but his Nets tenure also failed to reproduce Jefferson’s established offensive role. New Jersey’s C- grade reflects the risk of replacing an accomplished starter with a developmental forward and another veteran whose production had declined. The Nets were not buying a present All-Star with this trade, and the team’s later rebuild required other moves. Milwaukee’s advantage is based on its direct one-season scoring return, not on Jefferson’s eventual career with the Spurs and Warriors.

Final Verdict

Bucks Win. Milwaukee earns B+ for Richard Jefferson, who started all 82 games and averaged 19.6 points during 2008-09. New Jersey gets C- for Yi Jianlian and Bobby Simmons; Yi averaged 8.6 points in 61 Nets appearances. The Bucks acquired the more productive immediate player.

Research sources (5)