NBA Trade Verdict

Blackhawks Win

Tri-Cities traded Don Otten to the Washington Capitols for Jack Nichols on February 10, 1950. Authoritative Tri-Cities, Washington, league and Ben Kerner transaction records all show a straight player-for-player swap, correcting a legacy February 9 intake record that also listed an unsupported $5,000 cash payment to Tri-Cities. Nichols averaged 13.1 points in 18 games after the trade, later returned from military service and became a 15.8-point scorer for the Milwaukee Hawks in 1952-53. Otten averaged 14.9 points in 18 Washington games and returned for 16 more the next season. Tri-Cities gets the stronger long-term return.

February 10, 1950 Atlanta Hawks / Washington Capitols Record confidence: High

Trade Analysis

Tri-Cities Swapped Don Otten for Jack Nichols

On February 10, 1950, the Tri-Cities Blackhawks traded Don Otten to the Washington Capitols for Jack Nichols. Basketball-Reference's Tri-Cities and Washington transaction pages, the league transaction log and Ben Kerner's executive register all record the same straight swap. That evidence corrects two defects in the legacy Atlanta-franchise intake record: the transaction was dated February 9 and an additional $5,000 cash payment to Tri-Cities was listed. The authoritative records reviewed for this pass do not include cash.

Nichols Became a Productive Blackhawks Regular

Nichols immediately matched his Washington scoring rate. He played 18 regular-season games for Tri-Cities in 1949-50 and averaged 13.1 points and 3.4 assists, then averaged 19.7 points across all three of the Blackhawks' playoff games. He returned for six games in 1950-51 before military service interrupted his career. When Nichols came back in 1952-53, the franchise had moved to Milwaukee, and he became one of its leading players: 69 games, 15.8 points and 7.7 rebounds per game.

Washington Got a Shorter Otten Run

Otten was also productive right away. He played 18 games for the Capitols after the trade, averaged 14.9 points and shot .391 from the field, giving Washington a stronger interior scorer for the final stretch of the season. He also appeared in both of the Capitols' playoff games and scored 20.5 points per game. Otten returned for 16 Washington games in 1950-51 before the franchise folded, producing 148 points in that partial season.

The Direct Production Favors Tri-Cities

Both teams received productive players, which keeps this from being a one-sided failure. Otten gave Washington 34 regular-season games over parts of two seasons and was especially effective immediately after the trade. Nichols, however, ultimately delivered much more longevity to the Hawks franchise. Even with a military-service gap, he returned to the relocated Milwaukee club and produced a 69-game season at 15.8 points and 7.7 rebounds. That later value pushes the historical balance toward Tri-Cities.

Final Verdict

Blackhawks Win — Tri-Cities A-, Washington B. Tri-Cities traded Don Otten to the Washington Capitols for Jack Nichols on February 10, 1950. Authoritative Tri-Cities, Washington, league and Ben Kerner transaction records all show a straight player-for-player swap, correcting a legacy February 9 intake record that also listed an unsupported $5,000 cash payment to Tri-Cities. Nichols averaged 13.1 points in 18 games after the trade, later returned from military service and became a 15.8-point scorer for the Milwaukee Hawks in 1952-53.

Research sources (8)