NBA Trade Verdict

Pistons Win

Atlanta acquired Dick Mehen; Howie Schultz; cash from Pistons in exchange for Frank Brian.

May 4, 1951 Atlanta Hawks / Detroit Pistons Record confidence: Private Record

Atlanta Hawks Received

Trade Analysis

Atlanta Hawks Perspective

Atlanta sent out Frank Brian and received Dick Mehen, Howie Schultz, and additional consideration in a multi-asset exchange. The other team converted the exchange into a clearly superior result, while Atlanta's return fell short.

Detroit Pistons Perspective

Detroit clearly won the trade. Detroit's return centered on Frank Brian, while the outgoing package centered on Dick Mehen, Howie Schultz, cash. The incoming side produced the transaction's clearly superior long-term value. Contract timing, roster fit and Detroit's competitive window provide context, but the players and draft selections that actually materialized drive the verdict. The transaction has enough durable player value, draft consequence or franchise context to support substantive historical treatment.