NBA Trade Verdict

Knicks Edge

St. Louis sold Phil Rollins' player rights to the New York Knicks on December 17, 1960 for cash. Basketball-Reference's Hawks, Knicks and league transaction ledgers all preserve the same date and sale structure. Rollins had appeared in seven games for St. Louis earlier that season, then played 40 regular-season games for New York, averaging 5.8 points and 2.5 assists in 16.5 minutes per game. Those 40 games were the final NBA appearances of his career. The public ledgers do not preserve the cash amount New York paid. Because the Knicks received only a short half-season rotation return, the realized result is modest rather than a major win, but it still favors New York over an unquantified one-time cash return.

December 17, 1960 Atlanta Hawks / New York Knicks Record confidence: High

Atlanta Hawks Received

  • Cash cash

New York Knicks Received

Trade Analysis

The Knicks Bought Rollins from St. Louis

St. Louis sold Phil Rollins' player rights to New York for cash on December 17, 1960. The league and both team ledgers preserve the same date and direction. Rollins had played seven games for the Hawks earlier in the season before becoming a midyear Knicks addition.

Rollins Supplied a Useful Half Season

Rollins appeared in 40 regular-season games for New York, averaging 16.5 minutes, 5.8 points and 2.5 assists. Those were the final NBA games of his career, so the Knicks did not buy long-term upside, but they did receive a credible reserve role for the remainder of the season.

St. Louis Received an Unpriced Payment

No public ledger preserves the amount New York paid. That makes it impossible to compare the payment directly with the value of 40 games, and it keeps the Hawks from receiving anything more specific than credit for monetizing a player they no longer intended to use.

New York Won a Modest Rotation Deal

Forty games of usable guard play are enough to give the Knicks the better realized result. The short tenure and unknown price keep the margin modest. This was a successful depth purchase for New York, not a major loss for St. Louis.

Final Verdict

Knicks Edge — St. Louis C+, New York B. Phil Rollins gave the Knicks 40 useful games before his NBA career ended.

Research sources (4)