NBA Trade Verdict
Hawks Win
Atlanta acquired Joe Caldwell from Pistons in exchange for John Barnhill.
December 28, 1965 Atlanta Hawks / Detroit Pistons Record confidence: Private Record
Atlanta Hawks Received
- Player Joe Caldwell
Detroit Pistons Received
- Player John Barnhill
Trade Analysis
Atlanta Hawks Perspective
Joe Caldwell became an All-Star and one of Atlanta's leading two-way players. John Barnhill did not create similar long-term value for Detroit.
Detroit Pistons Perspective
The counterpart secured the transaction’s clearly superior realized value. Detroit’s return was led by John Barnhill, while the principal outgoing value was Joe Caldwell.