NBA Trade Verdict

Hawks Win

Atlanta acquired rights to Richie Guerin from Sonics in exchange for Dick Smith.

November 15, 1968 Atlanta Hawks / Oklahoma City Thunder Record confidence: Not Specified

Atlanta Hawks Received

Trade Analysis

Atlanta Acquired Richie Guerin’s Rights for Dick Smith

The Hawks acquired the rights to Richie Guerin from Seattle on November 15, 1968 and sent Dick Smith to the SuperSonics. The canonical record contains no additional pick or cash component.

Atlanta Reclaimed a Familiar Veteran Asset

Guerin had already been a major part of the Hawks’ organization, so the transaction brought his rights back into Atlanta’s control. The B+ grade reflects the stronger value assigned to that incoming rights asset.

Seattle Received Dick Smith as the Direct Return

The SuperSonics’ side is a single-player return. The canonical record does not show an additional asset attached to Smith that would materially narrow the value comparison.

The Hawks Receive the Better Grade

TradeVerdicts assigns Atlanta a B+ and Seattle a C. The result recognizes Atlanta’s stronger realized rights value while still crediting Seattle for receiving an actual player rather than an empty return.

Final Verdict

Hawks Win — Atlanta B+, Seattle C. Atlanta acquired rights to Richie Guerin from Sonics in exchange for Dick Smith.

Research sources (2)