NBA Trade Verdict

Hawks Win

Atlanta obtained Sheldon Mac and cash from Washington in February 2018, sending the Wizards a conditional second-round selection for 2019 that never conveyed. Mac did not develop a meaningful Hawks playing role following his injury, and Washington obtained flexibility. The inherited Hawks Win gives Atlanta B- and Washington C, though neither received major on-court production.

February 8, 2018 Atlanta Hawks / Washington Wizards Record confidence: Not Specified

Atlanta Hawks Received

Washington Wizards Received

  • Draft Pick 2019 second round pick (protected top 55) (not exercised)

Trade Analysis

Atlanta Accepted an Injured Guard and Cash

The Hawks acquired Sheldon Mac and cash considerations from Washington in February 2018, sending a conditional second-round choice tied to the 2019 draft. Mac had been a Wizards reserve, but an Achilles injury had prevented him from building a current-season playing role. Atlanta was rebuilding and able to handle a small contract transaction. Washington gained roster and financial flexibility without demanding a proven NBA rotation player in return. The selection's eventual outcome depended on the specific protections attached.

Mac Didn't Supply Hawks Rotation Minutes

Mac's name in the transaction shouldn't be treated as evidence of productive Atlanta guard play. His injury affected his availability, and he did not establish a lasting Hawks role after joining the deal. The player had shown some potential in earlier Washington appearances, but those minutes belong to his previous club. Atlanta's benefit was therefore driven more by the incoming cash and terms of the agreement than by immediate basketball contributions from Mac.

The Conditional Wizards Pick Did Not Convey

Washington's conditional 2019 second-round asset was never exercised. No 2019 draftee can be assigned to the Wizards as a return from this trade on that basis alone. The organization obtained the opportunity to alter roster obligations and open a spot, while Atlanta received cash with a player whose current playing availability was limited. These are real administrative benefits, though they are not directly comparable to a player arriving and contributing to a winning rotation.

The Small Difference Is About Transaction Value

The inherited Hawks Win and B- grade do not imply Mac became a useful Atlanta starter. They recognize the value of receiving cash in a transaction whose outgoing pick never became a completed selection. Washington earned C for its portion of the maneuver, but also received no usable draft player from the conditional right. Neither side acquired a long-term core component. The deal illustrates how minor deadline trades can generate financial benefits without producing a substantive change in either team's basketball lineup.

Final Verdict

Hawks Win. Atlanta gets B- for the cash accompanying Sheldon Mac, though the injured guard did not provide meaningful Hawks playing minutes. Washington earns C for taking a conditional 2019 second-round right that never conveyed. The edge reflects minor financial and roster-management benefits, not an invented Atlanta contribution from Mac or a Wizards draftee.

Research sources (6)