NBA Trade Verdict

Charlotte Hornets / New York Knicks / Philadelphia 76ers / Portland Trail Blazers Trade — 2023-02-09

Knicks Win

Knicks Win. New York earns A+ because Hart became a championship starter acquired for a manageable package. Portland receives B+ for Thybulle, Reddish and a first, a useful rebuilding return. Charlotte earns B- for second-round capital and a short-term player, while Philadelphia receives C+ because McDaniels did not become a durable playoff solution. Knicks Win is the completed-value verdict. New York clearly created the highest value. Hart became a foundational rotation player, then a starter-level connector whose rebounding, defense, transition play and chemistry with Jalen Brunson helped shape the Knicks' identity. He remained part of the starting group that won the 2026 championship. The acquisition cost was a protected first plus Reddish and Arcidiacono, a reasonable price for a player who became a durable postseason contributor and championship starter.

February 9, 2023 Charlotte Hornets / New York Knicks / Philadelphia 76ers / Portland Trail Blazers Record confidence: Medium

Charlotte Hornets Received

  • Player Svi Mykhailiuk
  • Draft Pick 2023 Philadelphia second-round pick later used on Colby Jones
  • Draft Pick 2027 second-round pick

Philadelphia 76ers Received

  • Player Jalen McDaniels
  • Draft Pick 2024 New York second-round pick later used on Cam Spencer
  • Draft Pick 2029 second-round pick

Portland Trail Blazers Received

Trade Analysis

Josh Hart four-team trade: What Actually Changed Hands

New York acquired Josh Hart in a four-team transaction. Portland received Cam Reddish, Matisse Thybulle, Ryan Arcidiacono and a 2023 first-round pick. Philadelphia received Jalen McDaniels plus second-round assets, while Charlotte received Svi Mykhailiuk and two second-round picks. The short summary focuses on Charlotte's portion, which can make the deal look like a McDaniels/Mykhailiuk swap; the full transaction shows why Josh Hart was the most important piece. That keeps the entire trade together in one account.

Josh Hart four-team trade: Where the Best Value Emerged

New York clearly created the highest value. Hart became a foundational rotation player, then a starter-level connector whose rebounding, defense, transition play and chemistry with Jalen Brunson helped shape the Knicks' identity. He remained part of the starting group that won the 2026 championship. The acquisition cost was a protected first plus Reddish and Arcidiacono, a reasonable price for a player who became a durable postseason contributor and championship starter. Team context still matters. B-range returns are clearly useful but less transformative. The verdict label describes the separation between the team grades.

Josh Hart four-team trade: What the Other Teams Still Received

Portland received a respectable package. Thybulle gave the Blazers defensive value, Reddish was a reclamation swing, and the first-round pick preserved real future capital. Philadelphia's McDaniels addition was short-lived and did not become a long-term piece, though the seconds added modest value. Charlotte's Mykhailiuk-and-seconds return was similarly limited but defensible for facilitating and moving McDaniels before free agency. Those returns keep the deal from being a one-team robbery, even though Hart's outcome towers over them. The analysis stays focused on the assets actually exchanged.

Why Every Team Entered, and Why Hart Moved the Balance

New York targeted Hart as an immediate complementary defender, rebounder and transition player around Jalen Brunson. Portland was seeking a first-round asset and a different roster structure, with Matisse Thybulle offering an outside defensive role and Cam Reddish another development option. Philadelphia wanted Jalen McDaniels for its postseason wing rotation; Charlotte moved McDaniels before his free agency for Mykhailiuk and second-round choices. Those motives were different, but the realized outcomes diverged: New York kept Hart through its 2026 NBA championship, whereas McDaniels never established a similar long-term Philadelphia role. The Portland first and Thybulle retained value without matching Hart’s starting contribution. The distinctions rest on each franchise’s direct assets, not projected careers of draft picks held by other teams.

Final Verdict

Knicks Win — New York A+, Portland B+, Charlotte B-, Philadelphia C+. Josh Hart became a long-term New York starter and contributed to the Knicks’ 2026 title, a much greater realized return than the cost of Reddish, Arcidiacono and a protected first. Portland obtained Thybulle and draft capital with value of its own, while Charlotte gained two seconds and Mykhailiuk and Philadelphia received a shorter McDaniels stint. The verdict credits Hart’s sustained Knicks role without dismissing the other teams’ asset returns or counting future picks as NBA players before their outcomes were established.

Research sources (8)