NBA Trade Verdict

Even Trade

Chicago Bulls received rights to Mike Smrek. Portland Trail Blazers received rights to Ben Coleman and rights to Ken Johnson (H.). Even Trade. Chicago Bulls is graded C+; Portland Trail Blazers is graded C+. The completed outcome is judged on realized player production, draft conversion and traceable downstream trade value rather than on the best later name merely associated with a pick.

June 18, 1985 Chicago Bulls / Portland Trail Blazers Record confidence: Medium

Chicago Bulls Received

Portland Trail Blazers Received

Trade Analysis

Smrek Rights for Two Sets of Rights

One day after the Gene Banks transaction, Chicago made a different kind of move: it acquired draft rights to Mike Smrek from Portland. The Trail Blazers received the rights to Ben Coleman and Ken Johnson. None of these outgoing assets was a cash payment or a completed trade of a signed star; the central questions concerned how each franchise could turn draft rights into usable players. Keeping the two June Bulls transactions separate is essential because their returns and participating teams were entirely different.

Chicago Consolidated, Portland Diversified

Chicago converted two rights positions into one targeted player right, Smrek. Portland took back rights to Coleman and Johnson, giving it two separate potential player avenues rather than a single comparable selection. The number of names by itself doesn't establish a winner. The valuation must follow the actual players attached to the rights rather than assign an automatic edge to Portland for acquiring two rights while Chicago received one. The source record specifically identifies all three players, allowing the two pathways to be compared without speculative substitutions.

An Even Assessment Reflects Limited Differences

Neither side's package is described in the retained verdict as producing an overwhelming basketball advantage. A third team wasn't involved, and no additional future pick needs to be invented to complete the asset chain. Chicago's outcome is tied to Mike Smrek, while Portland's is tied to the rights to Ben Coleman and Ken Johnson. That bounded comparison also guards against double counting production a player might have supplied elsewhere after his rights changed hands.

Final Verdict

Even Trade. Both Chicago and Portland receive C+. The Bulls exchanged two sets of draft rights for those of Mike Smrek, and the Trail Blazers accepted Coleman and Johnson's rights instead. With a similarly limited realized return in this comparison, a forced directional winner would exaggerate a narrow historical rights trade.

Research sources (5)