Detroit Sent a Young Guard to Chicago for a Reserve Forward
On June 17, 2016, Detroit exchanged 23-year-old guard Spencer Dinwiddie for Chicago forward Cameron Bairstow. A contemporaneous Pistons announcement framed the trade as a straightforward exchange of two players already fighting for NBA minutes. Dinwiddie was Detroit's No. 38 selection in 2014 and had appeared in 46 Pistons games across two seasons, spending stretches with the Grand Rapids Drive. Bairstow was Chicago's 2014 second-round selection, No. 49 overall, and had played 36 NBA games for the Bulls. Neither was an established starter or an expensive franchise centerpiece. The compelling story is what happened when each new employer made its first roster decision.
Chicago Waived Dinwiddie Twice Without Playing Him in the NBA
The Bulls released Dinwiddie on July 7, re-signed him July 28 and waived him again on October 21, 2016, after the preseason. He consequently never recorded a Chicago Bulls NBA regular-season appearance. The trade's direct Chicago return is an evaluation period and summer-league participation, not the points and assists Dinwiddie produced elsewhere. He did spend nine games with the Windy City Bulls after the waiver, averaging 19.4 points, 8.1 assists and 3.7 rebounds in the Development League. That G League affiliation illustrates talent Chicago could observe, but it was not an NBA contract retained by the Bulls at the time of his subsequent career breakthrough.
Detroit Released Bairstow Before Opening the Next Season
The Pistons also received no new regular-season playing production from their incoming player. Bairstow had made all 36 of his NBA appearances as a Bull before the trade. Detroit waived him on July 7, 2016, less than three weeks after acquiring him. There is no Pistons rotation stint to weigh against Dinwiddie's unrealized Chicago opportunity. Bairstow's pre-trade Bulls box scores are not a return to Detroit, just as Dinwiddie's 46 games with Detroit before June 2016 cannot count as Chicago production. Both sides acquired a player, conducted their roster evaluation and ended their NBA control before that player could make a regular-season appearance for the receiving club.
The Brooklyn Breakout Exposes an Opportunity Cost, Not Chicago Production
Brooklyn signed Dinwiddie to an NBA contract on December 8, 2016, after his nine-game Windy City spell, and he grew into a productive NBA guard with the Nets. That outcome makes Chicago's decision to release him look painful in hindsight, especially because Detroit had previously given up his rights in exchange for a forward it soon waived. But the Nets' signing was an independent transaction and Brooklyn's future seasons were not value Chicago retained from the Bairstow trade. The canonical Even Trade and matching B- grades describe the two clubs' similarly limited direct realized returns. They should not be used to imply Dinwiddie's later NBA success occurred with Chicago or that Detroit obtained Bairstow production.
Final Verdict
Even Trade — Chicago B-, Detroit B-. The Bulls obtained Spencer Dinwiddie but waived him twice before he played a Chicago NBA regular-season game. The Pistons acquired Cameron Bairstow and waived him July 7, 2016, also without a Detroit regular-season appearance. Dinwiddie's subsequent Windy City G League performances and December 2016 Brooklyn signing explain the opportunity Chicago failed to keep, rather than a basketball return it realized. Both receiving teams got effectively no NBA on-court contribution from this specific exchange.