NBA Trade Verdict

Cleveland Cavaliers / Indiana Pacers Trade — 1981-06-08

Cavaliers Win

Cleveland's James Edwards compensation package sent Indiana the 1981 second-round pick used on Ray Blume and a 1982 second-rounder later used on Guy Morgan. Edwards played 92 Cavaliers regular-season games, including 77 starts at 16.7 points and 7.5 rebounds in 1981-82. Indiana immediately traded Blume's rights with another future second-round pick for Mike Olliver, who never played an NBA game, while Morgan appeared in only eight Pacers games. Cleveland clearly captured more realized value.

June 8, 1981 Cleveland Cavaliers / Indiana Pacers Record confidence: High

Cleveland Cavaliers Received

  • Consideration Pacers agreed to not exercise their right of first refusal on veteran free agent James Edwards

Indiana Pacers Received

  • Draft Pick 1981 second round pick (#36-Ray Blume)
  • Draft Pick 1982 second round pick (#40-Guy Morgan)

Trade Analysis

What Changed Hands

Cleveland's June 8, 1981 compensation agreement concerned the restricted-free-agent signing of James Edwards from Indiana. The Pacers agreed not to exercise their right of first refusal over Edwards. In return, Indiana obtained two Cavaliers second-round draft selections, one in 1981 that became No. 36 for Ray Blume and another in 1982 that became No. 40 for Guy Morgan. The signing itself is dated May 25 in team transaction histories; June 8 identifies the compensation package rather than a second acquisition of Edwards.

How the Realized Value Separated

Edwards supplied Cleveland with a productive starting center. He played 77 Cavaliers games in 1981-82, starting 75, and averaged 16.7 points, 7.5 rebounds and 1.5 blocks in 33 minutes. He appeared in 15 more games in 1982-83, bringing his direct Cleveland service to 92 appearances. The Cavaliers later traded Edwards together with a separate 1983 first-round selection to Phoenix for Jeff Cook and two picks. Because the 1983 first was also sent, that entire later return cannot be credited solely to Edwards.

Reading the Team Grades

Indiana's two second-round selections produced little direct Pacers participation. The No. 36 choice became Ray Blume, whose rights Indiana traded to Chicago the next day along with an additional second-round pick for Mike Olliver. Olliver never played a regular-season NBA game. The other acquired selection became Guy Morgan at No. 40 in 1982; Morgan played eight Indiana games. Ray Blume's later 49 Chicago appearances belong to the Bulls, not Indiana. The difference supports Cleveland's canonical A- versus Indiana's C.

How Each Team Viewed the Trade

The archived Cavaliers Win rests on Edwards' 92 Cleveland games, most of them as an effective starter, against eight direct Indiana games from Morgan and a complicated Blume rights exchange. The Pacers did receive real draft consideration; it just produced limited measured return, and the additional pick they paired with Blume prevents sole credit for acquiring Olliver. The correct historical chronology distinguishes Edwards' May 25 signing, the June 8 compensation agreement, and the separate 1983 transaction that ended his Cleveland tenure.

Final Verdict

Cavaliers Win — Cleveland A-, Indiana C. In exchange for Indiana declining to match James Edwards' free-agent signing, Cleveland surrendered the second-round selections used at No. 36 on Ray Blume and No. 40 on Guy Morgan. Edwards played 92 Cavaliers games, including a 77-game starting-center season with 16.7 points per game. Morgan appeared eight times for Indiana; Blume's rights later moved to Chicago in a separate trade requiring another Pacers selection. The signing and compensation dates are distinct.

Research sources (7)