NBA Trade Verdict

Cavaliers Win

Cleveland acquired Lee Nailon and 2006 second round pick (#42-Daniel Gibson) for 2006 conditional second round pick (if Cavaliers finish with at least third best record in the league) (not exercised), producing a clear Cavaliers win on realized player, draft and roster value.

February 23, 2006 Cleveland Cavaliers / Philadelphia 76ers Record confidence: High

Cleveland Cavaliers Received

  • Player Lee Nailon
  • Draft Pick 2006 second round pick (#42-Daniel Gibson)

Philadelphia 76ers Received

  • Draft Pick 2006 conditional second round pick (if Cavaliers finish with at least third best record in the league) (not exercised)

Trade Analysis

The realized return clearly favored Cleveland. Cleveland received Lee Nailon and 2006 second round pick (#42-Daniel Gibson), while the other team received 2006 conditional second round pick (if Cavaliers finish with at least third best record in the league) (not exercised). The Cleveland return supplied the superior combination of player contribution, draft outcome and roster fit; the outgoing side did not create comparable franchise value. The grade reflects realized value, contract and age context, the eventual use of draft assets and the transaction’s effect on Cleveland’s competitive window.