NBA Trade Verdict

Cavaliers Win

Cleveland acquired Luke Walton, Jason Kapono and 3 additional assets for Ramon Sessions, Christian Eyenga and Cavaliers' option to swap first round pick (least favorable of Cavaliers 2013 first round pick, Heat 2013 first round pick (protected top 10), Kings 2013 first round pick (protected top 13)) with Lakers 2013 first round pick (protected top 14 in 2013, else extinguished) (2013 #30-Nemanja Nedovic), producing a clear Cavaliers win on realized player, draft and roster value.

March 15, 2012 Cleveland Cavaliers / Los Angeles Lakers Record confidence: High

Cleveland Cavaliers Received

  • Player Luke Walton
  • Player Jason Kapono
  • Draft Pick conditional first round pick (protected top 14 in 2012, else 2014) (2012 #24-Jared Cunningham)
  • Draft Swap Cavaliers option to swap first round picks (least favorable of Cavaliers 2013 first round pick, Heat 2013 first round pick (protected top 10), Kings 2013 first round pick (protected top 13)) with Lakers 2013 first round pick (protected top 14 in 2013, else extinguished) (2013 #19-Sergey Karasev)
  • Cash cash

Los Angeles Lakers Received

  • Player Ramon Sessions
  • Player Christian Eyenga
  • Draft Swap Cavaliers option to swap first round pick (least favorable of Cavaliers 2013 first round pick, Heat 2013 first round pick (protected top 10), Kings 2013 first round pick (protected top 13)) with Lakers 2013 first round pick (protected top 14 in 2013, else extinguished) (2013 #30-Nemanja Nedovic)

Trade Analysis

Cleveland Sold a Short-Term Guard for Draft Capital

Cleveland moved Ramon Sessions and Christian Eyenga to the Lakers at the 2012 trade deadline and took back Luke Walton, Jason Kapono, cash, a lottery-protected 2012 first-round pick and the right to swap a 2013 first. The veterans were not the point of the transaction. Cleveland was rebuilding, Sessions could opt out after the season, and the Cavaliers used the deal to convert a useful guard into additional draft control. The structure matched the franchise's timeline far better than simply keeping Sessions through a losing season.

The 2012 First Helped Cleveland Move Up for Tyler Zeller

The Lakers' 2012 first conveyed at No. 24, where Cleveland selected Jared Cunningham. One day later, the Cavaliers packaged Cunningham with Jae Crowder and Bernard James in a draft-night deal with Dallas for Kelenna Azubuike and the rights to Tyler Zeller, the No. 17 pick. Zeller became a regular Cleveland starter over the next two seasons. The incoming first therefore created more value than Cunningham's own NBA career suggests because Cleveland immediately used it as part of a move up the board.

The 2013 Swap Produced Another First-Round Upgrade

Cleveland also exercised the 2013 swap right. Basketball-Reference records the Cavaliers moving from the least favorable first they controlled to the Lakers' No. 19 slot, which became Sergey Karasev, while Los Angeles ended up with the No. 30 asset associated with Nemanja Nedovic. Karasev was not a major NBA success, but the mechanism still delivered exactly what a rebuilding team wanted: another opportunity to improve draft position. Walton contributed veteran minutes, while Kapono was waived almost immediately, so the draft pieces carried the long-term case.

Sessions Helped the Lakers, but Only for One Postseason Run

Los Angeles did get useful short-term production. Sessions played 23 regular-season games for the Lakers, started 19 and averaged 12.7 points with 6.2 assists, then started all 12 playoff games as the team reached the second round. That immediate help keeps the Lakers' side from grading as a disaster. The problem is duration: Sessions left after the season, Eyenga barely played, and Los Angeles surrendered both a first-round pick and a valuable swap right for a point guard rental. Cleveland retained the stronger aggregate value.

Final Verdict

Cavaliers Win — Cleveland A-, LA Lakers C+. The Lakers got a productive 23-game run from Ramon Sessions and used him as a playoff starter, so the deal addressed an immediate need. Cleveland, however, turned a player with an uncertain future into a 2012 first-round pick, a 2013 first-round swap, cash and salary ballast. The 2012 pick became part of the Tyler Zeller draft-night package, and Cleveland exercised the 2013 swap for the No. 19 slot. Los Angeles bought short-term help; Cleveland acquired multiple pieces of rebuild capital and won the transaction on lasting value.

Research sources (6)