What Changed Hands—and What Lasted
Denver sent guard Jim Price and its 1979 first-round pick to Detroit on February 1, 1978, and received Ralph Simpson. The team and league transaction histories agree on that core package. An older entry attached a 1979 second-rounder and a 1980 third-rounder to Denver's incoming side, but neither additional pick is established by the authoritative transaction logs. The first-round pick, in contrast, was real and eventually became No. 15 Phil Hubbard.
Why Detroit's First-Round Return Secured the Verdict
Detroit earned a better basketball return on both timelines. Price played 34 games for the Pistons, scoring 11.5 points per game before his departure generated a separate 1980 second-round compensation selection. Denver got 32 appearances from Simpson, averaging 5.5 points. More importantly, Detroit used the Nuggets' 1979 first-rounder on Hubbard, whose 196 Pistons games made that asset substantially more durable than Simpson's brief stint.
The Denver Nuggets Franchise's Return
Denver did not receive nothing. Simpson played in 32 games after the trade and later figured in the multi-asset package that brought George McGinnis and Mike Evans from Philadelphia. But the Nuggets sent Simpson alongside Bobby Jones and another first-round choice, making it wrong to attribute the entire McGinnis return to this one 1978 acquisition. Denver's C+ recognizes limited on-court service and qualified downstream trade utility.
The Detroit Pistons' Return
Detroit's A- reflects Price's short productive stint, the later compensation from his departure and the No. 15 selection used on Hubbard. Hubbard then appeared as one part of the four-asset package Detroit traded for Kenny Carr and Bill Laimbeer in 1982. The Pistons Win verdict does not give Hubbard sole credit for Laimbeer's career. It recognizes a superior set of traceable returns from Price and the first-round asset.
Final Verdict
Pistons Win, Detroit A- and Denver C+. Price produced 34 games for Detroit, and the 1979 first-round selection became Phil Hubbard, a 196-game Pistons contributor who later retained transaction value. Denver received 32 Ralph Simpson games and subsequently traded him as one element of a larger package. The independently sourced asset list excludes unsupported second- and third-round additions.