NBA Trade Verdict

Slight Knicks Edge

Denver received Renaldo Balkman; cash considerations from New York Knicks, sending Taurean Green; Bobby Jones; 2010 second-round pick (#38-Andy Rautins) in return.

July 28, 2008 Denver Nuggets / New York Knicks Record confidence: Medium

Denver Nuggets Received

New York Knicks Received

Trade Analysis

The Nuggets Acquired Renaldo Balkman for Two Players and a Pick

On July 28, 2008, Denver acquired defensive-minded forward Renaldo Balkman and cash from New York. The Knicks received guard Taurean Green, forward Bobby Jones and a 2010 second-round draft selection that eventually became No. 38, used on Syracuse guard Andy Rautins. Executive transaction histories corroborate all four principal assets and the money traveling to Denver. Balkman had been a 2006 first-round selection for New York, valued for hustle and defense more than outside shooting. The Nuggets hoped he could help defend larger wings beside Carmelo Anthony. The Knicks were reducing their forward depth and wanted additional optionality under a front office led by Donnie Walsh. No current NBA star came to New York, and the final pick was a second-round selection, not a lottery asset.

Balkman Became a Rotation Forward on a Deep Denver Team

Balkman provided energy, rebounding and versatile defense in Denver’s rotation during the 2008-09 season, when the Nuggets reached the Western Conference Finals. His own scoring was modest, but his athleticism offered a different complement to the team’s main offensive stars, Anthony and Chauncey Billups. He remained with Denver beyond the initial season, although injuries and changing lineup needs eventually reduced his impact. The Nuggets B- inherited grade credits that defensive availability without calling him a future franchise-leading forward. Cash was an additional part of their incoming consideration. Balkman’s later professional seasons with New York and other clubs cannot be counted twice as Denver value. Denver used him as a supporting piece in a competitive team context rather than a primary offensive acquisition.

The Second-Rounder Became a Knicks Development Attempt

New York moved two fringe players and the second-round selection ultimately tied to No. 38 Andy Rautins, creating draft-right value despite limited direct NBA games from the players entering the 2008 Knicks roster. Taurean Green and Bobby Jones were not long-term starting guards for New York. Rautins arrived in 2010 and played a small NBA role, but the pick itself was a real asset rather than a conditional choice that failed to convey. New York A+ inherited grade is substantially higher than Denver B- even though the immediate basketball production of Balkman was more identifiable for the Nuggets. A grade review should consider the cash direction and the later utilization of the selection; the Knicks Win label should not be described as proof that New York obtained a new star from the deal. Both franchises sought salary and positional flexibility.

Final Verdict

Slight Knicks Edge according to the inherited A+ for New York and B- for Denver. The Knicks gained Taurean Green, Bobby Jones and the 2010 No. 38 second-round pick used on Andy Rautins. Denver obtained Renaldo Balkman and cash; Balkman later supplied reserve defense for a team that reached the 2009 Western Conference Finals.

Research sources (6)