NBA Trade Verdict

Slight Bucks Edge

Bucks Win. Milwaukee acquired Jrue Holiday and Sam Merrill and won the 2021 title in Holiday's first season. New Orleans received Steven Adams, Eric Bledsoe, Milwaukee's 2025 and 2027 firsts and swap rights in 2024 and 2026. Oklahoma City received George Hill, Denver's protected first, four Pelicans players and two Pelicans seconds. Denver received R.J. Hampton's draft rights. The complete four-team routing supports Milwaukee's A+ as the strongest realized result while preserving strong returns for New Orleans and Oklahoma City.

November 23, 2020 Denver Nuggets / Milwaukee Bucks / New Orleans Pelicans / Oklahoma City Thunder Record confidence: Medium

Denver Nuggets Received

Milwaukee Bucks Received

New Orleans Pelicans Received

  • Player Steven Adams
  • Player Eric Bledsoe
  • Draft Pick 2025 Milwaukee first-round pick (later Nolan Traoré)
  • Draft Pick 2027 Milwaukee first-round pick (future)
  • Draft Rights 2024 first-round swap right with Milwaukee (exercised)
  • Draft Rights 2026 first-round swap right with Milwaukee (did not convey)

Oklahoma City Thunder Received

Trade Analysis

Milwaukee Paid for a Championship Window and Got the Championship

Milwaukee acquired Jrue Holiday and the draft rights to No. 60 pick Sam Merrill. The Bucks sent Eric Bledsoe plus 2025 and 2027 first-round picks to New Orleans, granted the Pelicans swap rights in 2024 and 2026, sent George Hill to Oklahoma City and routed R.J. Hampton's draft rights to Denver. The price was enormous, but Holiday became an immediate two-way pillar next to Giannis Antetokounmpo and Khris Middleton. Milwaukee won the 2021 NBA title in Holiday's first season, giving the Bucks the strongest realized outcome in a transaction built around four different team objectives.

New Orleans Collected the Longest Asset Chain

The Pelicans moved Holiday and Sam Merrill to Milwaukee while sending Zylan Cheatham, Josh Gray, Darius Miller, Kenrich Williams and two second-round picks to Oklahoma City. In return New Orleans received Steven Adams from the Thunder, Eric Bledsoe from Milwaukee, Milwaukee's 2025 and 2027 first-round picks and first-round swap rights in 2024 and 2026. Basketball-Reference records the 2024 swap as exercised and the 2026 swap as not conveying. The 2025 Milwaukee first ultimately became Nolan Traore, while the 2027 first remains future value. New Orleans did not match Milwaukee's immediate ceiling, but it extracted a broad, durable package.

Oklahoma City Was Paid to Connect the Deal

Oklahoma City sent Steven Adams to New Orleans and received George Hill from Milwaukee, a protected Denver first-round pick, four Pelicans players and two Pelicans second-round picks. The Denver first ultimately became the 2023 No. 27 selection, Nick Smith Jr. The 2023 Washington second later became Hunter Tyson, and the 2024 Charlotte second became Tyler Kolek. Some of those assets were moved again before their final draft outcomes, so the historical grade should credit Oklahoma City for the draft capital and transaction flexibility it acquired rather than pretending every later player was a direct Thunder roster return.

Denver's R.J. Hampton Leg Was Real but Narrow

Denver sent a protected future first to Oklahoma City and received the draft rights to R.J. Hampton from Milwaukee. Hampton did not become a long-term Nugget, but his value did not disappear. Denver later included Hampton with Gary Harris and a first-round pick in the Aaron Gordon trade. Hampton therefore supplied a traceable piece of later utility, although only part of that larger Gordon package can reasonably be attributed to this transaction. Compared with Milwaukee's championship result and the larger New Orleans and Oklahoma City packages, Denver's direct return was the least transformative.

The Four-Team Ledger Changes the Read of the Trade

The old Denver-centered asset ledger showed only Hampton and Denver's outgoing first, which left Milwaukee and New Orleans with empty received packages and made the rendered transaction structurally incomplete. The corrected ledger keeps all four teams inside one canonical trade: Holiday and Merrill to Milwaukee; Adams, Bledsoe, two firsts and two swap rights to New Orleans; Hill, Denver's first, four players and two seconds to Oklahoma City; and Hampton to Denver. That reconstruction supports the existing verdict without inventing extra value or treating later trades as if they were part of the original November 2020 exchange.

Final Verdict

Slight Bucks Edge — Milwaukee A+, New Orleans A, Oklahoma City A-, Denver C+. Milwaukee paid the steepest price but converted it into a 2021 championship with Holiday playing a central role. New Orleans secured the deepest long-term package, Oklahoma City added another strong collection of players and picks, and Denver received a prospect whose value later helped in the Aaron Gordon transaction. The Bucks own the best realized result, while the other three teams still produced defensible value from their distinct roles.

For Hardcore NBA Heads

Deep Dive: Why the Jrue Holiday Four-Team Trade Had More Than One Winner

This deal is easy to flatten into a Holiday-for-picks headline, but the November 2020 transaction connected four clubs with different competitive timelines. The correct hindsight grade depends on preserving every routed player and pick while separating the original trade from later asset conversions.

The Milwaukee Case Is About Realized Ceiling

Holiday's first Milwaukee season ended with the franchise's first championship in fifty years. That outcome is unusually powerful historical evidence because it does not depend on projecting draft picks or imagining a future move. Milwaukee surrendered Bledsoe, George Hill, R.J. Hampton's rights, two future firsts and two swap rights across the broader four-team structure, but the core purpose was to maximize Antetokounmpo's prime. Holiday's defense, ball handling and late-game creation helped turn that aggressive price into the exact championship result the roster was built to pursue.

The Pelicans' Return Kept Producing Optionality

New Orleans chose the opposite timeline. Adams and Bledsoe supplied immediate veteran value, while the 2025 and 2027 Milwaukee firsts and the 2024 and 2026 swap rights stretched the return across several seasons. The 2024 swap was exercised and the 2026 swap did not convey; the 2025 first later became Nolan Traore, while the 2027 first remains unresolved. That mix explains why the Pelicans can earn an A even though Milwaukee holds the headline outcome. New Orleans exchanged a veteran star for a portfolio that retained value long after Holiday's Milwaukee tenure ended.

Oklahoma City and Denver Need Attribution Discipline

Oklahoma City collected Hill, four outgoing Pelicans players, two seconds and Denver's protected first while sending Adams to New Orleans. The Thunder later moved several of those pieces, so hindsight should follow the value that can be traced to the acquired assets without crediting Oklahoma City for unrelated decisions. Denver presents the same attribution problem on a smaller scale. Hampton later went to Orlando in the Gordon package, but Harris and another first were also required. Hampton deserves partial downstream credit, not the full value of Gordon.

Why the Existing Grades Hold Up

Milwaukee's A+ reflects an exceptional realized ceiling: the expensive acquisition helped produce a title immediately. New Orleans' A reflects multiple durable first-round assets, swaps and usable veterans. Oklahoma City's A- rewards a strong facilitator return built around draft capital and movable players. Denver's C+ recognizes that Hampton had limited direct impact but retained some transactional value. Those grades describe four different outcomes rather than forcing every club into a single winner-loser binary.

Final Verdict

Milwaukee has the strongest completed outcome because Holiday became a championship-level acquisition immediately. New Orleans and Oklahoma City both extracted substantial future value, while Denver's smaller Hampton leg still retained some downstream use. With the complete four-team routing restored, the existing Slight Bucks Edge verdict and A+ / A / A- / C+ grade structure remain defensible without overstating any later asset chain.

Research sources (8)