This legacy listing is retained only as a disputed historical record and is not treated as a separate NBA trade.
No separate canonical grade is recorded for Atlanta Hawks, Detroit Pistons.
The cited Fort Wayne and league transaction evidence does not support a December 22, 1950 cash purchase of Charlie Share from the Hawks. The imported row is a legacy source conflict, not a separately verified NBA trade.
The documented Share transaction in this period is Boston’s April 26, 1951 trade with Fort Wayne for Bill Sharman. That deal is independently preserved as its own canonical TradeVerdicts record and is supported by the Celtics, Pistons and league transaction logs.
Keeping the December row as another completed trade would create a false extra movement for Share and distort team and player relationship histories. Its value is archival only: it shows what the older source package claimed and why that claim was rejected.
TradeVerdicts therefore keeps the route private for provenance while excluding it from public/indexable treatment and hindsight grading. No winner or team grades should be invented for a transaction the surviving source record does not establish.
Record Superseded. This legacy listing is retained only as a disputed historical record and is not treated as a separate NBA trade. No team grade is assigned because the record is retained for provenance rather than treated as a completed transaction.