February 13, 1959: Yardley for Conlin, Not a Pick Package
Detroit sent George Yardley to the Syracuse Nationals in exchange for Ed Conlin on February 13, 1959. The Detroit, Syracuse and NBA league transaction ledgers agree on that date; an older February 7 reference should not override the three aligned records. Syracuse is the historical location of the franchise now indexed under Philadelphia. The two principals were both players, with no verified extra draft pick or cash consideration attached to this exchange. The relevant comparison is therefore direct: Yardley's subsequent 88 Nationals appearances against Conlin's 85 games for Detroit over parts of two seasons.
Yardley Brought Syracuse an Established Scoring Threat
Yardley had already established his high-level scoring résumé with the Pistons, including leading the league in scoring in 1957–58. After the midseason transfer, he appeared in 88 regular-season games for Syracuse across the remainder of 1958–59 and the complete 1959–60 season. His Nationals scoring averaged about 19.6 points per game, and he was selected to the 1960 NBA All-Star Game. Those Syracuse-only outcomes establish why the Nationals won this exchange even though Yardley had made his name elsewhere first. Detroit traded away a player capable of continuing to supply front-line offensive production.
Conlin Was an Actual Detroit Contributor, Not a Write-Off
Ed Conlin gave Detroit 85 regular-season appearances across portions of two seasons before the club moved him again in 1960. That is a real roster return and prevents the Pistons' side from being described as an empty trade. His Detroit stint nevertheless didn't approach Yardley's Syracuse scoring rate or All-Star-level peak. The canonical B-minus Detroit grade reflects useful playing time at a much lower impact level, whereas the Nationals' A-minus recognizes the immediate star-caliber return. Neither grade requires claiming Conlin never played or crediting Syracuse with seasons Yardley spent in Detroit.
A Nationals Win with Historical Team Names Preserved
The original player-for-player exchange and subsequent production support a Nationals Win rather than merely a Philadelphia 76ers win in the 1959 setting. Modern franchise navigation may use Philadelphia as the linked franchise identity, but Syracuse owned the team and received Yardley. The gap between a roughly 19.6-point scorer who made the 1960 All-Star team and a shorter-lived Pistons rotation return supports Syracuse's A-minus against Detroit's B-minus. The deal can still have made roster sense to Detroit at the time; a retrospective grade describes what those assets produced, not a claim that the Pistons deliberately surrendered value.
Final Verdict
Nationals Win — Syracuse/Philadelphia A-, Detroit B-. Detroit traded George Yardley for Ed Conlin on February 13, 1959. Yardley scored around 19.6 points per game in 88 Syracuse appearances and earned a 1960 All-Star selection; Conlin supplied 85 Detroit games. Both franchises obtained usable players, but Syracuse gained the stronger basketball return.