NBA Trade Verdict

Detroit Pistons / LA Clippers Trade — 1983-10-17

Clippers Win

Detroit traded Ricky Pierce to the San Diego Clippers on October 17, 1983 for the 1986 and 1987 second-round picks San Diego had acquired from the Lakers one week earlier. Detroit did not keep either pick: the Pistons immediately sent both to Phoenix for David Thirdkill. Thirdkill played 56 regular-season games for Detroit across 1983-84 and 1984-85, totaling 406 minutes and 106 points before he was waived. Pierce gave San Diego 69 games, 35 starts and 685 points in 1983-84, then became part of the 1984 package for Marques Johnson. The Clippers received the better realized return.

October 17, 1983 Detroit Pistons / LA Clippers Record confidence: High

Detroit Pistons Received

LA Clippers Received

Trade Analysis

Two Future Picks for Ricky Pierce

The Pistons' October 17, 1983, transaction with the San Diego Clippers exchanged Ricky Pierce for two second-round selections: one eventually identified as the 1986 No. 46 pick associated with Jeff Hornacek, and another identified as the 1987 No. 46 pick associated with Bruce Dalrymple. The dates attached to the selections describe the eventual draft endpoints, not players who arrived in Detroit in 1983. Pierce, meanwhile, gave the Clippers a player they could put into their rotation at once. That difference between future draft capital and immediate production is the deal's first useful comparison.

Detroit Didn't Keep the Picks Until Draft Night

The Pistons sent both selections to Phoenix on the very same date as part of the transaction that brought David Thirdkill to Detroit. Thirdkill then played 56 games and 406 minutes for the Pistons before being waived. Those are the directly traceable outcomes of Detroit's decision to redeploy the picks. Treating Hornacek and Dalrymple as players Detroit drafted or developed through this trade would be a factual error. Their names identify future pick endpoints; Detroit's actual subsequent return was Thirdkill.

San Diego Received a Working Guard

Pierce appeared in 69 games for the Clippers in 1983-84, starting 35 and producing 685 points in 1,280 minutes. He also later became part of San Diego's package in the 1984 transaction for Marques Johnson. That second deal shows additional asset usefulness, but other pieces in the package contributed to the return. Pierce's immediate Clippers minutes are already strong enough evidence that the incoming player carried real value without borrowing the whole Johnson transaction.

Why the Grades Favor the Clippers

The canonical verdict is Clippers Win, with San Diego graded B+ and Detroit C-. Detroit converted its two future picks into a short Thirdkill tenure, while the Clippers received Pierce's documented 1983-84 production and later traded him again. The difference is not because Detroit missed out on drafting Hornacek directly; that selection had already been moved elsewhere. The grade comparison rests on the path each franchise actually controlled and what those assets produced afterward.

Final Verdict

Clippers Win, San Diego B+ and Detroit C-. Pierce delivered 69 games and further asset utility. Detroit redeployed the incoming picks for Thirdkill, who played 56 games; Hornacek and Dalrymple identify later draft outcomes of selections no longer held by the Pistons.

Research sources (4)