NBA Trade Verdict

Detroit Pistons / Phoenix Suns Trade — 1983-10-17

Phoenix Suns Win

Detroit sent Phoenix two future second-round picks on October 17, 1983 for forward David Thirdkill. The Pistons had acquired those picks from San Diego earlier the same day for Ricky Pierce. Thirdkill gave Detroit only 46 games, no starts and 77 points in 1983-84 before being waived in November 1984. Phoenix used the 1986 pick at No. 46 on Jeff Hornacek, who became a six-season Suns starter and 1992 All-Star, then was a central piece of the Charles Barkley trade. The 1987 pick became Bruce Dalrymple, who never played in the NBA. Hornacek alone makes this a decisive Phoenix win.

October 17, 1983 Detroit Pistons / Phoenix Suns Record confidence: High

Phoenix Suns Received

Trade Analysis

Detroit Sent Two Future Picks to Phoenix for David Thirdkill

On October 17, 1983, Detroit traded two future second-round selections to the Phoenix Suns for forward David Thirdkill. The Pistons had acquired those same picks from the San Diego Clippers earlier that day in an exchange involving Ricky Pierce. That previous deal explains the assets' arrival in Detroit, but it was not compensation provided by Phoenix. The two choices eventually became Jeff Hornacek at No. 46 in 1986 and Bruce Dalrymple at No. 46 in 1987. The original Phoenix return was draft rights to two future selections; Detroit's return was one player.

Thirdkill Supplied 46 Pistons Games Before Being Waived

Thirdkill's Detroit stint was brief: 46 regular-season appearances during 1983–84, no starts and 77 total points. Detroit waived him in November 1984, well before either of the outgoing picks reached its draft year. Those specific numbers are why the Pistons' canonical D grade is defensible: the acquired forward provided some reserve availability but little sustained scoring or later asset value. Thirdkill's career outside Detroit cannot be counted as value realized by the Pistons, just as the club cannot be assigned credit for what Phoenix later did with its acquired picks.

Hornacek Alone Made Phoenix's First Pick Exceptional

Phoenix used the 1986 second-round choice at No. 46 on Jeff Hornacek. He became a six-season Suns contributor and starter, earned an NBA All-Star selection in 1992, and was a central outgoing piece in the deal that brought Charles Barkley to Phoenix. Hornacek's Suns playing career already dwarfed Thirdkill's 46 Pistons games without relying on the later Barkley exchange. The secondary asset path reinforces his value but must be described correctly: Phoenix also traded other players to Philadelphia, so the Barkley acquisition should not be attributed entirely to Hornacek or the 1983 trade.

The Dalrymple Pick Adds Context, Not a Second Star

Phoenix's 1987 second-rounder became Bruce Dalrymple, also at No. 46 overall, but Dalrymple never appeared in an NBA regular-season game. The Suns' A-plus grade therefore does not depend on claiming both drafted players succeeded. It follows from Hornacek's real Phoenix production and subsequent trade utility against Detroit's limited Thirdkill return. The 1987 choice was a legitimate second asset, yet produced no NBA player appearances. A Phoenix Suns Win with A-plus to Detroit D accurately credits the one exceptional pick without inventing a second successful selection.

Final Verdict

Phoenix Suns Win — Phoenix A+, Detroit D. The October 17, 1983 trade sent David Thirdkill to Detroit for 1986 and 1987 second-rounders. Thirdkill scored 77 points over 46 Pistons games. Phoenix drafted Jeff Hornacek at No. 46 in 1986; he became a 1992 All-Star and a later Barkley-trade component. The other selection, Bruce Dalrymple, never played an NBA game.

Research sources (9)