The Exchange
San Francisco traded Tom Gola to New York on December 5, 1962 for Willie Naulls and Kenny Sears. Basketball-Reference's Warriors and Knicks transaction pages, the league ledger and all three player histories agree on the date and package. The transaction moved one versatile veteran to New York in exchange for two established forwards whose best Knicks seasons were already behind them. That makes the deal more nuanced than a simple one-for-two headcount comparison.
New York Return
Gola immediately became a major Knicks rotation player. He played 52 games after the trade in 1962-63, averaging 12.0 points, 7.1 rebounds and 4.3 assists in 35.5 minutes per game. He followed with 74 games in 1963-64, 77 in 1964-65 and 74 in 1965-66. Across the four post-trade seasons, New York received 277 regular-season games. His scoring declined as he aged, but he continued to rebound, facilitate and fill multiple perimeter and frontcourt roles. The volume and continuity are the core of New York's realized advantage.
San Francisco Return
Naulls gave the Warriors 47 games for the remainder of 1962-63, averaging 11.0 points and 6.7 rebounds in 26.1 minutes per game. Sears played 54 games that season at 6.1 points and 2.6 rebounds, then returned for 51 games in 1963-64 at 3.3 points and 1.8 rebounds. San Francisco therefore received 152 combined regular-season games from the two players. Naulls was then sold to Boston in September 1963, producing an additional financial return, while Sears' NBA career ended after the 1963-64 season.
Hindsight Comparison
The Warriors did not come away empty. Naulls remained a useful scorer and rebounder for half a season, Sears supplied depth for a season and a half, and Naulls retained enough rights value to be sold. But the package was short-lived. Gola stayed with New York for four seasons and played nearly twice as many regular-season games by himself as Naulls and Sears combined for San Francisco. He also handled a much larger role immediately after the trade, including more than 35 minutes per game in the first partial season.
Final Verdict
Knicks Win, A/B. New York receives an A for acquiring four seasons and 277 games of useful two-way play from Gola. San Francisco receives a B because Naulls and Sears produced real short-term value and Naulls generated a later cash sale, but the combined player return lasted only 152 games. Confidence is high because the transaction structure, all three player identities and the season-by-season production are directly documented. The verdict reflects only verified transaction terms and realized team value.