NBA Trade Verdict

Nets Win

New Jersey sent Golden State second-round selections in 2005 and 2007 for veteran Clifford Robinson on February 14, 2005. The picks became Chris Taft at No. 42 and Stéphane Lasme at No. 46, while Robinson supplied New Jersey with depth through the 2006-07 season, including playoff minutes. Neither Warriors draftee established a comparable sustained rotation role. Nets Win: New Jersey A- and Golden State C.

February 14, 2005 Brooklyn Nets / Golden State Warriors Record confidence: Medium

Brooklyn Nets Received

Golden State Warriors Received

Trade Analysis

The Nets Spent Two Second-Round Picks on a Veteran Big Man

New Jersey acquired Clifford Robinson from Golden State on February 14, 2005, surrendering second-round choices in the 2005 and 2007 drafts. The Nets had a competitive core featuring Jason Kidd, Vince Carter and Richard Jefferson and wanted a defender who could switch between forward and center responsibilities. Robinson was a proven veteran but past his peak scoring years. Golden State chose two future chances to add lower-cost prospects rather than carrying the rest of the center's contract. The trade was recorded before the February deadline.

Robinson Contributed Across Several Nets Playoff Seasons

Robinson played the remainder of 2004-05 for New Jersey and stayed with the team through 2006-07, giving the Nets years of frontcourt defensive experience. He was useful as a veteran reserve and occasional starter when the club needed more size or a matchup option. The Nets reached the postseason in each of those years, although Robinson was not their primary scorer and his contribution varied with age and injuries. That practical availability was meaningful for a team focused on advancing past the opening playoff rounds.

The Draft Selections Became Taft and Lasme

The 2005 choice given to Golden State became Chris Taft, taken forty-second overall, while the 2007 choice became Stéphane Lasme at No. 46. Both were legitimate attempts to find athletic defensive big men late in the draft. Neither developed into a sustained Warriors rotation fixture. Taft made only a short series of NBA appearances, and Lasme's Warriors opportunity was even briefer before he later played for Miami. Golden State cannot use Lasme's other-team career or international seasons as evidence that its 2005 acquisition produced a dependable contributor.

The Nets Realized Their Role-Player Investment

New Jersey exchanged two uncertain second-round slots for frontcourt depth it could actually deploy on playoff teams. Golden State obtained the right to develop two younger athletes, which wasn't valueless, but the realized league production stayed limited. Robinson did not make the Nets championship contenders by himself, and his earlier Phoenix and Portland accomplishments should not be included. His sustained receiving-team presence nevertheless exceeded the combined Warriors careers of the two drafted players. The existing Nets-winning verdict was supported by the asset outcomes, not merely the reputation of the veteran.

Final Verdict

Nets Win. New Jersey earns A- for Clifford Robinson's defensive rotation work spanning the balance of 2004-05 through 2006-07 and multiple playoff appearances. Golden State receives C for the two second-round picks that became Chris Taft and Stéphane Lasme, neither of whom developed into sustained Warriors depth. The Nets secured the more useful direct return.

Research sources (6)