NBA Trade Verdict

Charlotte Win

Charlotte acquired Jason Richardson and Jermareo Davidson's draft rights from Golden State in 2007 for Brandan Wright's rights. Richardson started all 82 Bobcats games in 2007-08 and averaged 21.8 points, producing 1,788 points and 243 made three-pointers before a 2008 Phoenix trade. Wright played 98 Golden State games across 2007-08, 2008-09 and 2010-11. Charlotte Win: A- versus C+.

June 28, 2007 Charlotte Hornets / Golden State Warriors Record confidence: High

Charlotte Hornets Received

Golden State Warriors Received

Trade Analysis

The Bobcats Bought an Established Scorer With a Top-Ten Pick

Charlotte acquired shooting guard Jason Richardson and second-round prospect Jermareo Davidson's rights from Golden State on June 28, 2007. Golden State received the rights to Brandan Wright, selected eighth overall after a promising North Carolina freshman season. Richardson had already built a strong offensive résumé with the Warriors and came with a larger contract. Charlotte accepted that expense to secure immediate perimeter scoring. Golden State bet the younger big man could develop while opening space in its backcourt.

Richardson Gave Charlotte an 82-Game Scoring Season

The centerpiece played every game for Charlotte in 2007-08, starting all eighty-two and averaging 21.8 points. He scored 1,788 points, made 243 three-pointers and also averaged 5.4 rebounds. Those were meaningful results from a team that had lacked a consistent high-volume wing scorer. Richardson began the following season with the Bobcats before being traded to Phoenix in December 2008. His later Suns and Magic production cannot be charged to the Charlotte acquisition, but the fully productive first season is sufficient evidence of substantial value.

Wright's Warriors Development Was Interrupted by Injuries

Wright appeared in thirty-eight Golden State games as a rookie, then thirty-nine the following season as his role expanded. A shoulder problem cost him the entire 2009-10 campaign. He returned for twenty-one Warriors games in 2010-11 before the club sent him to New Jersey in a separate trade. His total direct Golden State return was ninety-eight regular-season appearances rather than the lengthier NBA career he eventually assembled with other franchises. He showed finishing ability but never matched Richardson's offensive responsibility for their receiving teams.

The Proven Starter Beat the Prospect Gamble

Charlotte got a player who immediately led its scoring attack for an entire season. Davidson's rights were a secondary sweetener rather than the decisive asset. Golden State received a top-ten prospect who played in shorter stretches and lost a season to injury, an outcome that made the transaction disappointing despite Wright's later NBA usefulness. The older Charlotte-winning assessment was directionally correct. Richardson's 1,788-point campaign supports a stronger Bobcats grade, while the Warriors still deserve credit for acquiring a player who did reach their rotation.

Final Verdict

Charlotte Win. The Bobcats earn A- after Richardson started all eighty-two 2007-08 games and produced 1,788 points with 243 made threes. Golden State gets C+ for ninety-eight games from Brandan Wright across three partial seasons. Wright's injuries and later career elsewhere limit the original Warriors payoff while Charlotte realized a proven scorer.

Research sources (6)