NBA Trade Verdict

Slight Rockets Edge

On January 22, 2016, the Clippers traded Josh Smith back to Houston along with cash and the rights to Sergei Lishchuk for the Rockets' draft rights to Maarty Leunen. Smith had appeared in 32 Clippers games that season but played 23 regular-season games for Houston after his return. Neither Lishchuk nor Leunen became an NBA regular for the receiving team. The Rockets obtained a short-term playing contributor for rights they could relinquish, whereas the Clippers largely cleared a role and roster space. Slight Rockets Edge, Houston B-, Clippers C-.

January 22, 2016 Houston Rockets / LA Clippers Record confidence: Medium

Houston Rockets Received

LA Clippers Received

Trade Analysis

The Clippers Sent Smith Back to the Rockets

On January 22, 2016, Los Angeles returned Josh Smith to Houston after a difficult partial season with the Clippers. The exchange also sent cash and the draft rights to Ukrainian big man Sergei Lishchuk to the Rockets, while Los Angeles acquired the rights to Maarty Leunen. Smith had joined the Clippers in the preceding offseason after playing for Houston during its 2015 playoff run. He averaged only 5.7 points in thirty-two Clippers appearances, and his minutes were disappearing as the team shifted more playing time to Cole Aldrich. The agreement therefore solved a roster-management problem for Los Angeles while offering Houston a familiar veteran.

Smith Played Another Twenty-Three Houston Games

Smith's second Houston stint in 2015-16 consisted of twenty-three regular-season games after the January transaction. Those appearances, rather than the fifty-five Rockets regular-season games from his separate 2014-15 signing, are the direct playing return of this trade. He offered size and a known style of passing from the frontcourt but did not reproduce the larger impact of the previous season's Western Conference Finals run. Even so, getting NBA minutes from a veteran player was more measurable than simply holding distant draft rights. Houston did not have to send a current rotation player back to Los Angeles to make this deal work.

Two Rights Assets Had Little Direct NBA Output

Lishchuk's rights moved to Houston, and Leunen's rights moved to Los Angeles, but neither player became an NBA rotation regular because of the transaction. Rights to an overseas prospect can retain administrative or negotiating value without ever converting into court time. The cash accompanying Smith belonged to Houston, not to the Clippers, and should not be reversed when recording who received which part of the package. The Clippers gained flexibility to continue with their other frontcourt reserves, having traded away a player who had fallen out of the main rotation. That benefit differs from a typical asset-based return involving draft picks with defined selection dates.

The Direct Player Return Gives Houston the Edge

Houston acquired a veteran with a useful history in the franchise and obtained a limited but genuine twenty-three-game contribution. Los Angeles moved away from a signing that was not working and avoided retaining another out-of-rotation contract. Those practical outcomes favor the Rockets, although a stronger victory would exaggerate what Smith actually accomplished after January. His past Houston success is relevant background, not earned minutes from this new transaction. Likewise, Leunen's and Lishchuk's international records do not equal NBA games for the clubs receiving their rights. The grading should reflect a narrow playing-value advantage rather than treating the rights swaps as major roster upgrades.

Final Verdict

Slight Rockets Edge. Houston earns B- for acquiring Josh Smith's twenty-three 2015-16 regular-season games along with Sergei Lishchuk's rights and cash. Los Angeles receives C- for moving a reserve who had fallen out of favor and taking Maarty Leunen's rights, without any resulting Clippers NBA games from those rights. Smith's fifty-five Houston appearances in 2014-15 came from an earlier free-agent signing and cannot be credited to this January 2016 trade.

Research sources (6)