NBA Trade Verdict

Indiana Pacers / Phoenix Suns Trade — 1980-11-25

Pacers Win

Indiana reacquired veteran guard Don Buse from Phoenix on November 25, 1980 for 1981 and 1982 second-round picks. Buse played 140 regular-season games for the Pacers across two seasons, including all 82 games with 78 starts in 1981-82 at 9.7 points and 5.0 assists. Phoenix did not make either selection. In June 1981, the Suns sent both picks back to Indiana for Dudley Bradley while also relinquishing a 1983 first-round swap option. Bradley played 64 games for Phoenix in 1981-82. Because Phoenix had to add another concession to convert the picks, Indiana gets the better realized return.

November 25, 1980 Indiana Pacers / Phoenix Suns Record confidence: High

Indiana Pacers Received

Phoenix Suns Received

Trade Analysis

The Two Picks Bought Indiana a Proven Guard

Indiana sent Phoenix its 1981 and 1982 second-round picks on November 25, 1980, bringing Don Buse back to the Pacers. Buse was no mystery prospect: his earlier Indiana years had established him as a capable organizer and defender. He played 58 games for Indiana over the rest of 1980-81, then all 82 games in 1981-82. His second season included 78 starts, 9.7 points, 5.0 assists and 2.0 steals per game. That sustained starting role is the central reason the trade favors the Pacers.

Phoenix Did Not Keep Either Draft Selection

The draft choices were later associated with Al Leslie at No. 37 in 1981 and Jose Slaughter at No. 43 in 1982. Phoenix did not actually draft either player. In June 1981, the Suns sent both picks back to Indiana in a separate deal for Dudley Bradley. Phoenix also surrendered an option to swap first-round selections in 1983. Any evaluation that credits Leslie and Slaughter directly as Suns draft choices misstates their actual asset path.

Dudley Bradley Provided a Limited Suns Return

Bradley played 64 Phoenix games in 1981-82, starting three and averaging 5.1 points. That is meaningful basketball production and should not be erased simply because the Suns lost the first trade in hindsight. But his acquisition was not purchased solely with the Buse picks: the additional 1983 swap concession was part of the Bradley exchange. Assigning all Bradley's production to the two original picks would over-credit Phoenix, while ignoring the branch altogether would be unfair.

Indiana Received Buse and Later Recovered Its Picks

The Pacers regained the two selections in the Bradley trade. Indiana used the 1981 pick on Leslie, who never appeared in an NBA regular-season game, and the 1982 pick on Slaughter, who played 63 Indiana games in 1982-83. Buse's 140 Pacers games already establish the principal return, and the pick reacquisition further complicates any claim that Phoenix retained lasting draft upside. The A-/B- grades recognize Indiana's stronger outcome while acknowledging the Suns' short-lived Bradley benefit.

Final Verdict

Pacers Win — Indiana A-, Phoenix B-. Don Buse appeared in 140 Pacers games after the deal, including 82 games and 78 starts in 1981-82. Phoenix used the two incoming second-round picks as trade currency for Dudley Bradley, but had to add a 1983 first-round swap option and received only 64 games from Bradley. Indiana later regained both original picks and received 63 NBA games from 1982 selection Jose Slaughter. The conclusion follows the traced transactions, not an incorrect assumption that Phoenix itself drafted Al Leslie or Slaughter.

Research sources (4)