NBA Trade Verdict

Indiana Pacers / Portland Trail Blazers Trade — 1983-08-18

Pacers Win

Indiana acquired the rights to Granville Waiters from Portland on August 18, 1983 for a 1984 second-round pick that became No. 26 Victor Fleming. Waiters immediately made the Pacers' roster and played 78 games as a rookie, then 62 more for Indiana in 1984-85. Portland used the pick on Fleming, but he never appeared in an NBA regular-season game. The realized return is therefore decisive: Indiana received 140 games and two seasons of center depth, while Portland's draft asset produced zero NBA games.

August 18, 1983 Indiana Pacers / Portland Trail Blazers Record confidence: High

Indiana Pacers Received

Portland Trail Blazers Received

Trade Analysis

From Package Size to Completed Outcome

Indiana obtained the rights to Granville Waiters from Portland on August 18, 1983, in return for a 1984 second-round pick. Portland ultimately used that choice at No. 26 to select Victor Fleming. The original trade exchanged a player's NBA rights for a future pick, rather than two established players under contract. Both franchises' transaction histories and the 1984 league ledger corroborate the swap without identifying cash or a third participant.

How Indiana Produced the Better Return

Waiters signed with Indiana and played 78 games in his rookie season, including eight starts and 1,040 minutes. He appeared in 62 more games the next year, giving the Pacers 140 appearances, 1,743 minutes, 476 points and 397 rebounds across two seasons. Those are reserve-center contributions, not star-level production, but they reflect actual on-court value from the rights Indiana acquired. By contrast, Fleming did not appear in an NBA regular-season game after Portland selected him.

How Indiana Pacers Played Out

The corrected canonical outcome is Pacers Win, with Indiana graded B- and Portland D. Indiana's B- recognizes two seasons of depth produced by Waiters, and Portland's D reflects a second-round selection that never generated NBA games for the Trail Blazers. The narrow transaction ledger does not support the older separate editorial claim that these returns were even or that both teams earned identical C grades. The value difference is grounded in actual appearances, not the number of pieces exchanged.

How the Portland Trail Blazers Played Out

Portland chose future selection flexibility over holding Waiters's rights, an understandable trade-day preference even when the player ultimately contributed elsewhere. Indiana chose a center it could put on its roster and obtained two seasons of service. The Trail Blazers' No. 26 selection became Fleming, whose NBA playing return was zero. This was a direct rights-for-pick transaction without an elaborate chain of later swaps, so the side receiving the usable player has the better documented result.

Final Verdict

Pacers Win, Indiana B- and Portland D. Waiters gave Indiana 140 games and 1,743 minutes after the Pacers acquired his rights in August 1983. Portland used the traded 1984 second-round pick on Victor Fleming at No. 26, but he never appeared in an NBA regular-season game. That source-supported gap favors Indiana despite the modest scale of the original rights-for-pick transaction.

Research sources (4)