NBA Trade Verdict

LA Clippers / New York Knicks Trade — 2008-11-21

Clippers Win

Los Angeles Clippers captured the stronger realized return in the 2008-11-21 transaction with New York Knicks, led by Zach Randolph; Mardy Collins.

November 21, 2008 LA Clippers / New York Knicks Record confidence: High

Trade Analysis

Two-for-Two Agreement Announced November 21

The Clippers announced on November 21, 2008 that they would receive Zach Randolph and Mardy Collins from the Knicks for Tim Thomas and Cuttino Mobley. Los Angeles wanted another frontcourt scorer after Elton Brand had departed, while New York was trying to create greater salary flexibility under its new management. The official Clippers release identifies exactly these four players, with no draft pick in the exchange. The announcement date is the preserved archive date, but the trade was finalized on November 25 after New York reviewed medical findings concerning Mobley. Those separate announcement and finalization dates should not become two trade records. Randolph came in as the established scorer; Collins was a younger guard prospect, and both names deserve an independent accounting.

Randolph Scored 20.9 a Night but Played Only 39 Clippers Games

Randolph averaged 20.9 points and 9.4 rebounds in 39 Los Angeles regular-season games during 2008-09, starting 34 and shooting 48.7 percent from the field. That was legitimate high-volume production for a club searching for another scorer. His Clippers stay nevertheless ended after that one partial season. In July 2009, Los Angeles traded him to Memphis for Quentin Richardson in a separate transaction. Randolph eventually became a cornerstone of the Grizzlies, but his 551 Memphis games are not additional Clippers performances from the Knicks exchange. The original acquisition brought immediate points and rebounds, not a lasting Los Angeles star tenure. The A-plus Clippers grade is inherited; it should be evaluated against this accurately bounded output instead of a claim of years of team control.

Collins Also Played 82 Clippers Games Across Two Seasons

Collins was more than an unexamined second name in the package. He played 39 regular-season games with Los Angeles in 2008-09, making 14 starts and averaging 5.9 points and 2.6 assists. In 2009-10 he added 43 Clippers appearances without a start, scoring 2.6 points and assisting on 1.0 basket per game. Across the two seasons, his Clippers contribution totaled 82 NBA appearances. Collins had appeared in nine early 2008-09 Knicks games before the deal, and those belong to New York, not to the receiving franchise. His short rotation run was less consequential than Randolph's scoring, but the first two seasons of player-specific records show actual depth from both Los Angeles acquisitions.

Thomas Played 36 Knicks Games; Mobley Played None

New York received 36 regular-season appearances from Thomas during 2008-09, with one start and averages of 9.6 points and 3.1 rebounds. The other incoming name did not take the court for the Knicks. Mobley underwent further testing after his trade physical raised concerns about his heart, then announced his retirement on December 11, 2008 because of hypertrophic cardiomyopathy. That medical issue delayed the trade finalization and ended his playing career, but it should not be framed as a performance decision made by New York or a prediction of what he might have produced. The Knicks gained Thomas's modest rotation minutes and financial-contract flexibility, while the Clippers received Randolph's 39 games and Collins's two-year 82-game stint.

Final Verdict

Clippers Win — Los Angeles A-plus, New York B-minus in the existing archive. The Clippers got Randolph's 39 games of 20.9-point, 9.4-rebound basketball and 82 Collins games over two seasons. The Knicks got 36 Thomas appearances and no Mobley games after his December 2008 retirement following medical testing. New York also pursued financial flexibility, while Randolph's later Memphis production is not Los Angeles team value.

Research sources (11)