NBA Trade Verdict

Slight Pelicans Edge

New Orleans Pelicans came out ahead in the 2009-06-25 transaction with Miami, which received 2010 second-round pick (#41-Jarvis Varnado); 2012 second-round pick (#34-Jae Crowder) for rights to Marcus Thornton.

June 25, 2009 Miami Heat / New Orleans Pelicans Record confidence: High

Miami Heat Received

New Orleans Pelicans Received

Trade Analysis

Miami received 2010 second-round pick (#41-Jarvis Varnado); 2012 second-round pick (#34-Jae Crowder) and sent rights to Marcus Thornton in the 2009-06-25 transaction with New Orleans Pelicans. Marcus Thornton developed into a productive NBA scorer, while Miami's two second-round returns did not generate comparable direct Heat value. The grade is based on realized NBA production, draft conversion, contract/cap consequences and identifiable downstream use rather than the reputation of the assets at the moment of the deal. Miami still receives a C grade because the return was not valueless, but the stronger counterpart return earned a B+ in hindsight. The directional verdict therefore reflects a real value gap without assuming that every later development or injury outcome was foreseeable when the transaction occurred.