NBA Trade Verdict

Milwaukee Bucks / Phoenix Suns Trade — 1968-09-12

Bucks Win

Milwaukee acquired Dick Cunningham from Phoenix on September 12, 1968. The compensation record is unusually messy: Basketball-Reference lists John Arthurs, cash and a future second-round pick, while Pro Sports Transactions preserves contemporary reporting that the deal involved cash, Arthurs as the later player to be named and an informal claim on Milwaukee's 1970 first-round pick, which became the No. 16 slot. Cunningham gave the Bucks 295 regular-season games across six seasons and remained on the roster for the 1971 championship. Phoenix received real asset value, but the disputed draft-paper trail makes its completed return harder to measure.

September 12, 1968 Milwaukee Bucks / Phoenix Suns Record confidence: Medium

Phoenix Suns Received

  • Draft Pick 1970 first round pick (#16- Gary Freeman )
  • Conditional Asset player to be named later (John Arthurs on 1970-06-02)
  • Cash cash

Trade Analysis

A Veteran for an Expansion Franchise

Milwaukee's September 12, 1968, deal with the Phoenix Suns brought Dick Cunningham to the Bucks, then in their inaugural NBA season. The outgoing package was more complicated than a simple player swap: Phoenix received a future 1970 first-round pick, a player to be named later and cash. This was a team still establishing its roster exchanging future flexibility for a player it could use immediately. The transaction record identifies the later first-round selection as No. 16, associated with Gary Freeman, but the selection's draft endpoint and Milwaukee's direct basketball return are different categories of evidence.

The Pick and the Later-Named Player

The first-round pick is recorded as the 1970 No. 16 selection linked to Gary Freeman. A further obligation was fulfilled when John Arthurs was identified as the player to be named later on June 2, 1970. These details matter because the Suns' side consisted of multiple forms of consideration with different fulfillment dates. There is no reason to invent a particular dollar amount for the cash or to pretend Phoenix received all three items in the same form on trade day. The future selection and later naming were genuine obligations in the agreement.

Milwaukee's Return Was Cunningham

The Bucks received Cunningham, a direct roster addition during their first season, rather than an unexercised option. His presence had immediate usefulness in a franchise trying to put an NBA team on the court. The B+ Milwaukee grade is assessed against the complete outbound package rather than against only the later John Arthurs obligation or only the 1970 selection. Phoenix's C reflects the other side of a transaction with several pieces whose value and timing were different from a veteran available right away.

Why the Bucks Get the Edge

Bucks Win is the recorded verdict, Milwaukee B+ over Phoenix C. The comparison is not as straightforward as the number of assets suggests: the Suns received a first-round pick, a delayed player obligation and cash, while Milwaukee obtained the player it sought. Cunningham's near-term usefulness provides a coherent reason for the Bucks' favorable assessment. A stronger claim about the cash's exact worth or the entire later career of the eventual draft pick would require supporting evidence that the transaction notes do not supply.

Final Verdict

Bucks Win, Milwaukee B+ and Phoenix C. Cunningham supplied an immediate player return to the new franchise. Phoenix received a 1970 first-round selection, a later-named player and cash, whose amount is not documented in the preserved notes. Those terms, not a fictional single-player swap, define the judgment.

Research sources (4)