NBA Trade Verdict

SuperSonics Win

Milwaukee acquired veteran center Jim Fox from Seattle on October 22, 1975 for a 1976 second-round pick that became No. 19 Bayard Forrest. The legacy archive entry incorrectly added cash; Basketball-Reference's Bucks, SuperSonics, league and executive transaction ledgers all show the exchange as Fox for the pick only. Fox gave Milwaukee 70 games in 1975-76, averaging 3.9 points and 3.4 rebounds in 13.1 minutes, plus three playoff appearances. Seattle used the pick on Forrest, then traded Forrest to Phoenix in March 1977 for a 1979 second-round pick. That pick later joined another second-rounder in Seattle's acquisition of John Johnson, who became a regular on the 1978 Finals team and 1979 championship team. Seattle wins in hindsight because the draft asset retained and compounded value well beyond Fox's one useful reserve season in Milwaukee.

October 22, 1975 Milwaukee Bucks / Oklahoma City Thunder Record confidence: High

Milwaukee Bucks Received

Oklahoma City Thunder Received

  • Draft Pick 1976 second-round pick (No. 19 Bayard Forrest )
  • Cash unsupported legacy cash claim

Trade Analysis

The Verified Package Was Jim Fox for One Second-Round Pick

Milwaukee, Seattle, the NBA league transaction ledger, Wayne Embry's executive record and Bill Russell's executive record all align on the same October 22, 1975 structure: the Bucks received Jim Fox and Seattle received a 1976 second-round draft pick. None of those ledgers lists cash. This review therefore removes the legacy cash component from the verified package and simplifies the pick language to what the primary records actually support. The pick was later used at No. 19 on Bayard Forrest.

The Pick Had Come to Milwaukee Through the Atlanta Penalty

Milwaukee's 1974-75 transaction ledger shows that on June 5, 1975 the Bucks received two 1976 second-round picks from Atlanta as a league remedy tied to the Hawks' earlier signing of Milwaukee draft pick Julius Erving. Basketball-Reference identifies those two picks as the selections later used on Alex English and Bayard Forrest. By October, Milwaukee moved the Forrest pick to Seattle for Fox. That provenance is important because the legacy phrase about the most favorable Bucks pick is unnecessary and is not how the authoritative October transaction ledgers describe the deal.

Fox Gave Milwaukee One Useful Reserve Season

Jim Fox played 70 games for the 1975-76 Bucks, averaging 3.9 points and 3.4 rebounds in 13.1 minutes. He also appeared in all three games of Milwaukee's first-round playoff series against Detroit. The production was modest compared with his earlier Seattle seasons, but it was real roster value for a Milwaukee team in transition after the Kareem Abdul-Jabbar trade. Fox should not be treated as a failed acquisition simply because his role had shrunk; the Bucks received a durable veteran backup for the entire regular season.

Seattle Turned the Pick Into Bayard Forrest and Then Another Pick

Seattle selected Bayard Forrest with the No. 19 pick in the 1976 draft. Forrest never played a regular-season game for the SuperSonics, but that did not end the asset chain. On March 18, 1977 Seattle traded Forrest to Phoenix for a 1979 second-round pick. The transaction record identifies that future pick as the one later used on Paul Mokeski after Seattle sent it onward. Forrest himself later played 139 NBA games for Phoenix, but those Suns games are not credited to Seattle; Seattle's realized value is the replacement draft asset it received for him.

The Forrest Pick Helped Seattle Acquire John Johnson

On October 22, 1977 Seattle sent the Phoenix-derived 1979 second-round pick and a 1980 second-round pick to Houston for John Johnson. Because two picks were required, the original Fox trade deserves only partial credit for Johnson rather than full credit for the entire acquisition. Even with that discount, the downstream value is substantial. Johnson played 76 games for Seattle in 1977-78 as the SuperSonics reached the NBA Finals, then started all 82 games in 1978-79 and averaged 11.0 points, 5.0 rebounds and 4.4 assists for the NBA champions.

Final Verdict

SuperSonics Win, A-/C+. Seattle receives an A- because a single second-round pick retained value through multiple transactions and became part of the package for a starting forward on consecutive Finals teams, including the 1979 champion. The grade stops short of a full A because the Johnson acquisition also required another second-round pick. Milwaukee receives a C+ because Fox supplied 70 regular-season games and three playoff appearances as a dependable reserve, but the Bucks surrendered the more durable asset and received no comparable downstream return. Confidence is high on the corrected package, Fox's Milwaukee production, Forrest's No. 19 selection and the later Forrest-to-Phoenix and Johnson transactions. The verdict reflects only verified transaction terms and realized team value.

Research sources (13)