NBA Trade Verdict

New Orleans Pelicans / Orlando Magic Trade — 2004-02-19

Even Trade

New Orleans acquired Shammond Williams from Orlando Magic for Sean Rooks.

February 19, 2004 New Orleans Pelicans / Orlando Magic Record confidence: Medium

Orlando Magic Received

Trade Analysis

It Was the New Orleans Hornets, Not the Pelicans

The New Orleans franchise acquired guard Shammond Williams from Orlando on February 19, 2004, sending veteran center Sean Rooks to the Magic. The current franchise taxonomy calls the team the Pelicans, but the club was then the New Orleans Hornets. The identity matters for readers looking up the original deadline transaction. This was a straight player swap rather than a trade of future first-round picks or a broader three-team package.

Williams Added Guard Depth; Rooks Offered Size

Williams was a backcourt player with shooting and ballhandling experience. Rooks gave Orlando a veteran center with frontcourt size. The teams therefore exchanged different positional tools, likely reflecting their respective rotation needs at the deadline. The source-backed asset list contains one player received by each team, so there is no justification for describing hidden draft compensation or attaching an unrelated later roster deal to the outcome.

Equal B-minus Grades Reflect a Fair Small Exchange

The Hornets/Pelicans and Magic each receive B-minus. Both sides obtained an experienced NBA player with a credible role, but neither trade return should be treated as a franchise-changing acquisition. The balanced assessment credits the specific guard-versus-center exchange without assuming identical skills or identical statistical production. A different position can fill a genuine roster need even when the two assets receive the same retrospective grade.

Final Verdict

Even Trade — New Orleans Hornets/Pelicans B-minus, Orlando B-minus. New Orleans gained Shammond Williams and sent center Sean Rooks to the Magic. The clubs exchanged veteran depth at different positions, and neither documented return creates a strong case for a clear winner.

Research sources (3)