NBA Trade Verdict

New Orleans Pelicans / Philadelphia 76ers Trade — 2013-07-12

Pelicans Win

New Orleans acquired Jrue Holiday and Pierre Jackson's rights from Philadelphia for Nerlens Noel's rights and a 2014 first-round pick that became Elfrid Payton. Holiday developed into the Pelicans' two-way leader and later returned a major pick package. Philadelphia acquired two meaningful young assets, but New Orleans realized the greater direct and downstream value.

July 12, 2013 New Orleans Pelicans / Philadelphia 76ers Record confidence: High

New Orleans Pelicans Received

Philadelphia 76ers Received

  • Draft Rights rights to Nerlens Noel
  • Draft Pick first round pick (protected top 5 in 2014-19, else 2019 second round pick, 2020 second round pick) (2014 #10-Elfrid Payton)

Trade Analysis

New Orleans Took a 23-Year-Old All-Star, Philadelphia Took Two Draft Assets

On July 12, 2013, the Pelicans acquired Jrue Holiday and 2013 second-round draft rights to Pierre Jackson from the 76ers. Philadelphia received the rights to Nerlens Noel, New Orleans' No. 6 selection that year, and a 2014 first-round choice protected inside the top five. The Pelicans' dated announcement confirms both legs and identifies Jackson as the No. 42 pick. Holiday had already played four NBA seasons and made an All-Star team. Noel, selected after a serious knee injury, offered a cheaper defensive upside bet rather than immediate minutes. This was a trade of established guard production for a 2013 prospect and a future first-round right, not a direct Holiday-for-Noel swap.

Holiday’s Injury-Interrupted Early Seasons Made the Price Look Steep

Holiday did not immediately produce a full, healthy year for New Orleans. His 2013-14 debut was shortened to 34 games by a stress fracture, and his 2014-15 season included 40 appearances. The Pelicans had acquired him to share creation responsibilities with Anthony Davis but could not collect full-season value in those first two campaigns. Their risk was real: a top-five-protected future first and a lottery big carried longer-term options that Holiday's early injury history briefly obscured. The acquisition nevertheless brought an established professional rather than an inexperienced guard, and New Orleans retained his contractual rights while he recovered. Injuries are a debit against the immediate return, not evidence that the subsequent productive seasons happened outside the 2013 transaction.

His 2017-18 Defense and Portland Series Delivered the Playoff Case

The most direct argument for the Pelicans comes from Holiday's healthy 2017-18 season. The team's official season review recorded 81 games and 81 starts, and the NBA's player statistics list 19.0 points and 6.0 assists per appearance. In the first round, New Orleans swept Portland while Holiday helped contain Damian Lillard and provided offense against the Trail Blazers' backcourt. He earned NBA All-Defensive first-team honors for that season. New Orleans lost the next series against Golden State, so the 2013 trade should not be described as having delivered a title or even a conference finals appearance. It delivered high-value regular-season guard minutes and a specific playoff achievement the club could point to.

Philadelphia’s Protected First Became Payton, Then Several Other Rights

The 2014 New Orleans first transferred to Philadelphia as the No. 10 pick and became the draft rights to Elfrid Payton. The 76ers promptly traded those rights to Orlando for the No. 12 rights to Dario Šarić, a future first-round consideration and an additional future second. Orlando's July 2014 announcement independently names all three incoming Philadelphia assets. The first-round consideration was a previously owed Philadelphia pick being sent back from Orlando, an important protection from future obligation rather than a newly drafted star. This was a genuine conversion of the asset New Orleans sent in 2013, but it would be misleading to count Payton's seasons with Orlando as Philadelphia playing production. Šarić eventually played for the 76ers and later became one part of the separate November 2018 Jimmy Butler trade.

Noel Produced Philadelphia Minutes Before a Separate Dallas Move

Noel missed the 2013-14 season while rehabilitating his knee, then developed into a shot-blocking and steals-producing center for Philadelphia. He was a genuine young contributor rather than a draft asset that never reached the floor. On February 23, 2017, Philadelphia sent him to Dallas for Justin Anderson, Andrew Bogut and a protected future first. The NBA's contemporary trade tracker makes clear that this Dallas exchange was separate from the 2013 Holiday deal; its assets cannot be credited to New Orleans. The value the Sixers collected included Noel's own defensive seasons and any value they could realize in moving him later. That supports the inherited 76ers B, even though it did not approximate Holiday's best New Orleans seasons.

The 2020 Milwaukee Package Extended Holiday’s New Orleans Asset Path

New Orleans traded Holiday again in November 2020, seven seasons after acquiring him. The later four-team transaction brought Eric Bledsoe and George Hill along with three future first-round draft picks and two pick swaps in the broader Milwaukee-led package, according to the NBA's official summary. That was a second, separately negotiated trade, not compensation Philadelphia sent in 2013. It is still fair to show that the Pelicans held a valuable asset they could later move for more options. The exact downstream players chosen with those rights require their own transaction history and shouldn't all be assigned to Holiday by shorthand. Viewed through that boundary, the original deal provided both prolonged high-level two-way play and a later resale opportunity. Philadelphia's parallel rebuilding route was legitimate, but its direct result never matched the full New Orleans guard return.

Final Verdict

Pelicans A, 76ers B — New Orleans edge. Holiday supplied multiple seasons of elite defensive guard play, notably 81 starts and a Portland playoff sweep in 2017-18, before New Orleans moved him for another major package in 2020. Philadelphia received Noel's real NBA contribution and the top-five-protected first that became No. 10 Payton rights, then Šarić rights and further pick considerations through Orlando. The 2014 and 2020 follow-up trades are separate transactions and cannot be treated as guarantees of a title or of every later drafted player's career.

Research sources (15)