NBA Trade Verdict

Lakers Win

New York moved 38-year-old Patrick Ewing through a four-team deal and received a large package of veterans and picks. The decision to move on was defensible, but the return never produced a durable successor core.

September 20, 2000 Los Angeles Lakers / New York Knicks / Phoenix Suns / Sonics Record confidence: Medium

Los Angeles Lakers Received

New York Knicks Received

Phoenix Suns Received

  • Player Chris Dudley
  • Draft Pick 2001 first round pick (lottery protected) (#18-Jason Collins)

Sonics Received

  • Player Patrick Ewing (Sr.)

Sonics

B-

Trade Analysis

Patrick Ewing’s Exit Was Not a Two-Team Trade

New York sent its longtime center Patrick Ewing to Seattle in a four-team agreement with Phoenix and the Los Angeles Lakers. Ewing was 38 and near the end of his career, so the Knicks were trying to transition rather than swap a prime franchise superstar for equivalent current talent. New York received a large group of veterans and multiple draft selections.

The Knicks Received Quantity, Not a New Foundation

Glen Rice, Luc Longley, Travis Knight, Vernon Maxwell, Vladimir Stepania and Lazaro Borrell joined New York through different legs of the transaction. The incoming draft rights included two first-round picks and two second-round picks. That was a broad compensation package, but its combined long-term contribution did not provide a new organizational centerpiece comparable with the Ewing era.

The Lakers Acquired Horace Grant and Others

Los Angeles sent Rice and Knight to New York and received Horace Grant, Greg Foster, Chuck Person and Emanual Davis from Seattle. Grant supplied experienced defense and rebounding for a championship-level Lakers roster. Phoenix received Chris Dudley and a Knicks first-round pick, while Seattle acquired Ewing. The initial local Lakers inbound list is empty and must be corrected.

Why the Lakers Held the Best Position

Los Angeles exchanged peripheral pieces and Rice’s outgoing contract situation for a veteran frontcourt fit, while the Knicks had understandable reasons to begin a transition. Seattle’s upside was limited by Ewing’s age, and Phoenix used its participation to secure draft value. Evaluating each team’s distinct purpose supports the inherited Lakers Win without implying New York had no reasonable motive.

Final Verdict

Lakers Win. Horace Grant provided a strong veteran fit for a contender, while the Knicks accumulated several players and picks that did not become a new long-term core. Seattle received late-career Ewing and Phoenix obtained Dudley plus a first-round asset. All four return packages belong in the rendered ledger.

Research sources (2)