NBA Trade Verdict

New York Knicks / San Antonio Spurs Trade — 2005-02-24

Slight Knicks Edge

New York holds a slight long-term edge because the return included Malik Rose plus first-round picks that became David Lee and Mardy Collins, while San Antonio received an immediate starting center in Nazr Mohammed who helped win the 2005 championship. The Spurs' title payoff keeps their grade high even though the Knicks captured more cumulative asset value.

February 24, 2005 New York Knicks / San Antonio Spurs Record confidence: Medium

New York Knicks Received

  • Player Malik Rose
  • Draft Pick first round pick (protected top 21 in 2005-09) (2005 #30-David Lee)
  • Draft Pick 2006 first round pick (protected top 10) (2006 #29-Mardy Collins)
  • Cash cash (Rose's trade kicker)

Trade Analysis

New York Received Rose and Two Firsts

The February 24, 2005 transaction sent Nazr Mohammed and Jamison Brewer from New York to San Antonio. The Knicks received Malik Rose, a protected 2005 first-round pick, a protected 2006 first-round pick and cash related to Rose's trade kicker. That made the return more extensive than a swap of two veteran big men. San Antonio wanted immediate center help for a championship run, while New York accepted a veteran and two chances to turn draft selections into longer-lived players. Both motivations were visible in the assets exchanged.

Mohammed Helped Deliver the 2005 Championship

Mohammed quickly became useful at center for the Spurs and contributed during their successful 2005 NBA championship postseason. That is direct value for the acquiring team at the exact competitive moment the trade was designed to address. He was not merely an expiring contract, and his continued service in the following season added to the return. San Antonio had a defensible reason to surrender picks for a center who could help immediately. The championship payoff supports a high grade even when New York's longer-term draft results are evaluated separately.

The Knicks Converted One First into David Lee

The 2005 first-round pick became No. 30, used on David Lee, who grew into an All-Star-level contributor for New York. The 2006 pick became No. 29 Mardy Collins, while Rose supplied veteran frontcourt depth. Lee's production gave the Knicks a valuable multiyear result from a transaction made during a less successful team period. The two clubs therefore realized different forms of value: a championship role from Mohammed for San Antonio and several seasons of player development from Lee in New York. The latter provides the slight retrospective edge.

Final Verdict

Slight Knicks Edge. New York earns A for Malik Rose and draft assets led by the 2005 selection used on David Lee. San Antonio receives A- for Nazr Mohammed's immediate 2005 championship contribution, with Jamison Brewer also in the package. Both sides benefited, but Lee supplied more cumulative direct value across later seasons.

Research sources (8)