NBA Trade Verdict

New York Knicks / Oklahoma City Thunder Trade — 2017-09-25

Knicks Win

New York turned an aging Carmelo Anthony with a restricted trade market into useful veterans and the pick that became Mitchell Robinson, while Oklahoma City received one uneven season before paying additional draft value to move Anthony again.

September 25, 2017 New York Knicks / Oklahoma City Thunder Record confidence: Medium

New York Knicks Received

Trade Analysis

Anthony's No-Trade Clause Framed the September 2017 Exit

New York transferred Carmelo Anthony to Oklahoma City on September 25, 2017, receiving Enes Kanter, Doug McDermott and the Chicago-origin 2018 second-round selection. Anthony had spent more than six seasons with the Knicks and his contractual no-trade protection limited the destinations New York could realistically consider. Oklahoma City had already acquired Paul George to play beside Russell Westbrook and wanted another established scorer. The Knicks instead obtained two immediately usable players and a future draft choice, separating the current roster from Anthony's sizable contract. No first-round pick moved directly in the original exchange, and the deal did not include Dennis Schroder or Emmanuel Mudiay. Those players entered separate later trades, each with additional outgoing consideration. Keeping these transactions distinct is essential when assigning value to the original three incoming New York assets.

Kanter Became an Immediate Knicks Rebounding Starter

Kanter was the largest immediate NBA contributor New York obtained. He appeared in 71 Knicks regular-season games in 2017-18, starting every one, while averaging 14.1 points and 11.0 rebounds in 25.8 minutes. His 59.2 percent field-goal shooting gave the club an efficient interior finisher, though his defense and changing roster role made the longer tenure more complicated. Kanter stayed with New York into 2018-19 before the franchise waived him in February 2019. His Knicks performances were direct results of the September 2017 exchange rather than hypothetical development of a draft right. The first season was especially tangible: he played a regular starting role when the team was moving past Anthony. His subsequent appearances for Portland, Boston and other organizations should not be added to the direct Knicks return.

McDermott Played Fifty-Five Games Before Helping Bring Mudiay

The other incoming veteran, Doug McDermott, supplied New York 55 regular-season games in 2017-18, with averages of 7.2 points and 2.4 rebounds. He made 38.7 percent of his three-pointers while working primarily as a reserve wing. On February 8, 2018, the Knicks sent McDermott to Dallas and a separate 2018 second-round pick to Denver as part of a three-team transaction that brought Emmanuel Mudiay to New York. The Knicks' own release confirms those outgoing assets and the three clubs. The separate second was not the Chicago-origin pick acquired from Oklahoma City in September, which New York retained. McDermott's time with the Knicks was brief, but it created real shooting minutes and a movable contract that played a part in another negotiation. Mudiay was not acquired for McDermott alone.

The Chicago Second Turned Into Mitchell Robinson at No. 36

The 2018 second-round selection acquired from Oklahoma City originated with Chicago. New York used it at No. 36 in the June 2018 draft to choose Mitchell Robinson, a center who developed into a durable rim protector and offensive rebounder. His value required more than draft-night reputation: the Knicks controlled his rights, signed him, and used him for multiple seasons as a rotation center and eventual regular starter. Unlike the McDermott deal, which required a separate New York second-round right, this pick was kept through the draft. Robinson's NBA games therefore belong directly to the acquiring team and constitute a long-running return from the Anthony trade. The No. 36 selection produced a lasting Knicks center and supports New York's A grade without portraying Kanter or McDermott as future All-Stars.

Anthony Played Seventy-Eight Games for Oklahoma City

Oklahoma City received one actual season from Anthony. He played 78 regular-season games in 2017-18, averaging 16.2 points and 5.8 rebounds as a third scoring option behind Westbrook and George. The Thunder won 48 games, finished fourth in the Northwest Division and lost to Utah in six games during the first round of the playoffs. Those figures make the acquisition more than a zero-return salary transaction, but they also reflect a different role from Anthony's highest-usage Knicks years. His fit on a team with two established ball-dominant stars proved difficult, and the franchise chose not to continue the arrangement into the next season. Oklahoma City's C-plus reflects Anthony's 78 games and a playoff berth, but not an extended title window.

The 2018 Atlanta Exit Cost Oklahoma City an Additional First

The Thunder's second transaction involving Anthony came in July 2018, after his only Oklahoma City season. In a three-team deal with Atlanta and Philadelphia, Oklahoma City sent Anthony and a protected 2022 first-round pick to the Hawks, receiving Dennis Schroder from Atlanta and Timothe Luwawu-Cabarrot from Philadelphia. Atlanta also obtained Justin Anderson, while Philadelphia received Mike Muscala. The official Thunder announcement makes clear that Schroder was not supplied by New York in 2017 and the new draft compensation was a separate outgoing asset. Any analysis that credits Schroder's entire later Thunder production as a free return from the original Knicks trade omits the additional first-round cost and other teams involved. The extra transaction and limited Anthony tenure help explain why New York's lasting Robinson right aged more favorably.

Final Verdict

Knicks Win — New York A, Oklahoma City C+. Anthony played 78 Thunder games at 16.2 points before a 2018 first-round exit and a separate three-team trade in which Oklahoma City also sent a protected 2022 first. New York received 71 Kanter starts, 55 McDermott games, and the Chicago-origin No.36 second used on Mitchell Robinson. McDermott later joined a separate Mudiay deal involving another Knicks second.

Research sources (14)