NBA Trade Verdict

Orlando Magic / Phoenix Suns Trade — 2003-12-23

Even Trade

Orlando acquired 2004 second round pick (#36-Antonio Burks) from Phoenix Suns for Donnell Harvey.

December 23, 2003 Orlando Magic / Phoenix Suns Record confidence: Medium

Orlando Magic Received

Trade Analysis

Orlando Moved Harvey for a 2004 Draft Opportunity

On December 23, 2003, the Magic traded forward Donnell Harvey to Phoenix for a 2004 second-round selection. That choice became No. 36, used on Antonio Burks. The transaction was a classic shift in development timing: Orlando surrendered a player already in the league in exchange for a chance to make a choice months later. Phoenix acquired someone who could be evaluated as frontcourt depth during the current season.

Harvey and Burks Played Very Different Positions

Harvey supplied rebounding and physicality as a forward, while Burks offered guard potential once Orlando converted the selection. That distinction makes the two returns hard to compare by an identical statistical category. The relevant question is whether Phoenix received useful short-term forward minutes or Orlando gained a better longer-term roster piece with the No. 36 pick. Neither incoming asset was a proven cornerstone at the time of the exchange.

The Matching C Grades Recognize Limited Upside

The Magic and Suns each receive C. Orlando did exercise the selection on a named guard, giving its side a verifiable draft conversion, and Phoenix obtained Harvey’s playing rights. Neither return generated an established high-impact franchise piece in the recorded trade assessment. The equal score is a modest verdict on those two outcomes rather than a broader claim about each club’s subsequent rebuild.

Final Verdict

Even Trade — Orlando C, Phoenix C. Orlando acquired the 2004 No. 36 pick later used on Antonio Burks; Phoenix received Donnell Harvey. The sides exchanged current frontcourt depth for a later guard prospect, and the documented basketball return does not establish a durable advantage for either.

Research sources (4)