NBA Trade Verdict

Royals Win

Rochester purchased Ed Mikan's player rights from the Chicago Stags on December 12, 1949. Mikan had averaged 5.1 points in 21 Chicago games that season, then gave the Royals 44 regular-season appearances at 3.7 points per game. His most visible Rochester contribution came in the playoffs, where he averaged 13.0 points across two games despite the Royals' early elimination. The cash amount is not preserved in the reviewed transaction record. Rochester gets a modest historical edge because the purchase added useful depth to a 51-win contender, while Chicago monetized a player whose regular-season role declined after the move.

December 12, 1949 Chicago Stags / Sacramento Kings Record confidence: High

Chicago Stags Received

  • Cash cash

Trade Analysis

Rochester Bought Ed Mikan from Chicago

On December 12, 1949, the Chicago Stags sold Ed Mikan's player rights to the Rochester Royals for cash. Basketball-Reference lists the acquisition on Rochester's 1949-50 transaction page and in the league transaction log. Mikan was not an obscure reserve: he had been the fifth overall pick in the 1948 BAA Draft and averaged 9.9 points across all 60 games for Chicago as a rookie. His role had already diminished in 1949-50, however, falling to 5.1 points through 21 Stags games.

Mikan Became a 44-Game Royals Reserve

Mikan appeared in 44 regular-season games for the Royals after the purchase. He averaged 3.7 points and 0.6 assists while shooting .299 from the field, a clear reduction from his rookie-season scoring role. Rochester did not need him to carry the offense: the Royals went 51-17 behind Bob Davies, Arnie Risen and a deep veteran roster. Mikan's most notable contribution came in the postseason.

The Stags Sold a Shrinking Role

Chicago received cash for a player whose role had already contracted. Mikan had played every game and averaged 9.9 points in 1948-49, but he was down to 5.1 points across 21 games before the sale. The Stags remained excellent without him, finishing 40-28 and reaching the playoffs. Because the cash amount is unknown, Chicago's financial return cannot be measured or linked to a specific later roster addition.

A Small Playoff Contribution Tips It to Rochester

The realized value is modest on both sides. Rochester got 44 regular-season games from Mikan and a surprisingly productive two-game playoff showing, which is useful depth for a 51-win contender. Chicago got an undisclosed cash payment and did not suffer an obvious competitive decline tied to the move. The original placeholder analysis overstated the transaction as a major franchise win; Mikan never became a high-impact Rochester centerpiece.

Final Verdict

Royals Win — Rochester B+, Chicago B. Rochester purchased Ed Mikan's player rights from the Chicago Stags on December 12, 1949. Mikan had averaged 5.1 points in 21 Chicago games that season, then gave the Royals 44 regular-season appearances at 3.7 points per game. His most visible Rochester contribution came in the playoffs, where he averaged 13.0 points across two games despite the Royals' early elimination. The cash amount is not preserved in the reviewed transaction record.

Research sources (5)