Bobby Layne

Pittsburgh acquired Hall of Fame quarterback Bobby Layne from Detroit for Earl Morrall, a 1959 second-round pick, and a 1960 fourth-round pick. Layne gave the Steelers credibility, production, and a different competitive identity in the late 1950s and early 1960s. Detroit did receive value, including Roger Brown, but the Lions moved a franchise icon and watched Pittsburgh get the player who defined the trade's legacy.

Detroit Lions received Bobby Layne from New York Yanks for Bob Mann / Bobby Mann. The recorded outcome favors Detroit Lions.

Detroit Lions received Bobby Layne from New York Yanks for Camp Wilson. The recorded outcome favors Detroit Lions.

Pittsburgh traded Bobby Layne's draft rights to Chicago for rights to Ray Evans. Layne became a Hall of Fame quarterback, while Evans never delivered comparable NFL value, making Chicago the clear winner.

Pittsburgh sent the rights to reigning NFL MVP Bill Dudley to Detroit and received a package that included the 1948 third overall pick (used on Bobby Layne). Dudley had won the 1946 rushing title and MVP; Layne would become a Hall of Fame quarterback. On the surface, trading the defending MVP for a package including the Layne pick seems reasonable, but the execution muddies the picture. Pittsburgh never maximized Layne, eventually letting him go (see 1947-0024) before he became an elite QB. Dudley continued producing elsewhere. Slight Pittsburgh lean given the draft capital acquired, but the downstream mismanagement of the Layne asset diminishes this win substantially