Player Trade Profile
David Howard (a) / Davie Howard
Explore every recorded NFL trade involving David Howard (a) / Davie Howard,
including the assets exchanged, team grades, final verdicts,
and TradeVerdicts analysis.
Trade Impact Summary
The TradeVerdicts database links David Howard (a) / Davie Howard to 2 public trade records involving Dallas Cowboys, New England Patriots, and Minnesota Vikings.
Each record below shows what the teams received, how each side
was graded, and the analysis behind the verdict. Grades and
verdicts follow the
TradeVerdicts methodology
.
Transaction Record
Related Trades
2 records Dallas Cowboys Win
Tier: major
Confidence: high
Dallas Cowboys received 1991 first round pick (#1-Russell Maryland) from New England Patriots for Ron Francis (b), David Howard (a) / Davie Howard, Eugene Lockhart, 1991 first round pick (#11-Pat Harlow), and 1991 second round pick (#41-Jerome Henderson). The recorded outcome favors Dallas Cowboys.
Assets Received
- Pick 1991 first round pick (#1-Russell Maryland)
- Player Ron Francis (b)
- Player David Howard (a) / Davie Howard
- Player Eugene Lockhart
- Pick 1991 first round pick (#11-Pat Harlow)
- Pick 1991 second round pick (#41-Jerome Henderson)
Trade Analysis
Dallas Cowboys received 1991 first round pick (#1-Russell Maryland), while New England Patriots received Ron Francis (b), David Howard (a) / Davie Howard, Eugene Lockhart, 1991 first round pick (#11-Pat Harlow), and 1991 second round pick (#41-Jerome Henderson). The recorded outcomes support the existing C+/C grades and Dallas Cowboys Win verdict.
View the full trade verdict
→ Dallas Cowboys Win
Tier: major
Confidence: high
The Herschel Walker trade became the NFL's most famous franchise-altering deal. Minnesota acquired the star running back, but Dallas turned the return into the foundation of a dynasty. The Vikings chased immediate contention. The Cowboys collected the assets that helped reshape their future, making this the benchmark for every blockbuster trade that followed. The deal remains the gold standard for a franchise-altering trade win.
Assets Received
- Player Herschel Walker
- Pick 1990 third round pick (#54-Mike Jones)
- Pick 1990 fifth round pick (#116-Reggie Thornton)
- Pick 1990 tenth round pick (#249-Pat Newman)
- Pick 1991 third round pick (#68-(Willie) Jake Reed)
- Player Jesse Solomon
- Player David Howard (a) / Davie Howard
- Player Issiac Holt
- Player Darrin Nelson
- Player Alex Stewart
- Pick 1990 first round pick (#21-(Bernard) Eric Green)
- Pick 1990 second round pick (#47-Dennis Brown)
- Pick 1990 sixth round pick (#158-James Williams (Edward))
- Pick 1991 first round pick (#11-Pat Harlow)
- Pick 1991 second round pick (#38-Darryl Lewis)
- Pick 1992 first round pick (#13-Eugene Chung)
- Pick 1992 second round pick (#40-Matt Blundin)
- Pick 1992 third round pick (#71-Kevin Turner)
Trade Analysis
Why the Vikings Made the Trade
Minnesota believed it was one player away from a Super Bowl. Herschel Walker was one of the biggest names in football and one of the most physically gifted running backs of his era. The Vikings viewed him as the final piece capable of pushing an already talented roster over the top.
That context matters. Minnesota was not a hopeless team buying a famous name for attention. The Vikings saw a window and attacked it. Walker's reputation made the price feel easier to justify in the moment because he looked like the kind of player who could carry an offense, punish defenses, and give Minnesota a matchup advantage every week.
What Dallas Actually Received
The trade is often remembered as the Herschel Walker deal, but the true story is the collection of assets Dallas acquired. The Cowboys gained players, draft choices, and conditional compensation that ultimately became far more valuable than Walker himself.
Dallas did not treat the return like a normal package. The Cowboys treated it like a roster-building engine. That is the key difference between the two sides. Minnesota was focused on the immediate star. Dallas was focused on volume, leverage, and future options.
How Jimmy Johnson Built a Dynasty
Dallas converted those assets into cornerstone value that helped form a championship foundation. The flexibility created by the Walker trade allowed the Cowboys to accelerate their rebuild and construct one of the greatest rosters of the modern era.
The genius was not simply making the trade. It was knowing what to do after the trade. Dallas kept turning the return into more opportunities, more roster depth, and more pathways to premium talent. That is why this deal became larger than a running back trade. It became a franchise construction case study.
Why the Deal Failed for Minnesota
Walker remained a productive player, but he never delivered the transformational impact Minnesota needed. That is the brutal part for the Vikings. They did not acquire a bad player. They acquired a good player at a historic cost.
The problem was opportunity cost. Minnesota surrendered an enormous amount of long-term value for a short-term star addition. A running back, even a famous and talented one, rarely changes everything alone. Walker needed the rest of the roster, the scheme, and the timing to match the price. They did not.
The Long-Term Legacy
Every huge NFL trade involving draft capital is still compared to this one. It became the league's ultimate warning about paying historic prices for one non-quarterback, especially when the selling team has a clear rebuilding plan.
The deal also shows the difference between acquiring a player and acquiring a future. Minnesota got the name. Dallas got the machinery to build a dynasty. That is why this trade still appears in almost every discussion of the biggest, best, and worst deals in NFL history.
Why This Trade Still Matters
This trade still matters because it became the model for turning one star into an entire roster-building machine. Dallas did not simply win the transaction. The Cowboys used the structure of the deal to build the foundation of a dynasty.
For Minnesota, it remains a warning about paying for the idea of one final missing piece. Walker was a major name, but the cost was too large, the fit was not transformative enough, and the long-term damage became impossible to ignore.
Final Verdict
This remains one of the clearest verdicts in NFL history. Dallas converted one star player into the backbone of a dynasty. Minnesota acquired the headline, but Dallas acquired the future. Cowboys grade: A+. Vikings grade: F.
View the full trade verdict
→ 