Santonio Holmes

Summary: Pittsburgh sent Super Bowl XLIII hero Santonio Holmes to the Jets for a fifth-round pick (which became QB John Skelton) following off-field issues. Holmes made the Pro Bowl in 2011 with New York. Analysis: Holmes still had significant football left — he made the 2011 Pro Bowl and was a legitimate starter. Pittsburgh received only a fifth-round pick, a modest return for a starting receiver and recent Super Bowl hero. The suspension context partially justifies the discount, but the price reflects Pittsburgh's limited leverage. Upgrading from "Slight Jets Edge" to Jets Lean; a fifth for Holmes was a significant underpay.

Summary: Pittsburgh moved up from the 32nd pick to 25th overall, sending two additional picks to New York to select Santonio Holmes. Holmes caught the Super Bowl XLIII game-winning touchdown and made one Pro Bowl. Analysis: Pittsburgh surrendered the 32nd pick (Mathias Kiwanuka, a solid pass rusher), a third (Gerris Wilkinson), and a fourth (Guy Whimper) to move up seven spots for Holmes. Holmes delivered a memorable Super Bowl performance and solid production for four seasons before off-field issues cut his Pittsburgh tenure short. The cost was three picks for a good-not-great receiver. The original "New York Giants Lean" understates Holmes's Super Bowl impact. Upgrading to a slight Pittsburgh lean.