NFL Trade Verdict

New York Giants Win

The Rams acquired the 1957 first-round pick that became Del Shofner from the New York Giants for Andy Robustelli. Robustelli became a Hall of Fame defensive end and championship cornerstone for New York, making the Giants the clear hindsight winner.

July 29, 1956 Los Angeles RamsNew York Giants Confidence: high Tier: major

Los Angeles Rams Received

Trade Analysis

New York Giants received Andy Robustelli and gave up 1957 first round pick (#11-Del Shofner). New York Giants receives the edge because the recorded return carries stronger long-term football value than the package credited to Los Angeles Rams.