NFL Trade Verdict
New York Giants Win
Detroit acquired 1959 fourth round pick (#46-Bob Grottkau) from New York Giants for Carl Karilivacz. The partner side holds a modest edge. Detroit received usable value, but the better realized production or draft conversion landed with New York Giants.
Detroit Lions Received
- pick 1959 fourth round pick (#46- Bob Grottkau )
New York Giants Received
- player Carl Karilivacz
Trade Analysis
New York Giants received Carl Karilivacz and gave up 1959 fourth round pick (#46-Bob Grottkau). New York Giants receives the edge because the recorded return carries stronger long-term football value than the package credited to Detroit Lions.