Miami acquired pick 78 in the 2003 draft from New England for…
Miami acquired pick 78 in the 2003 draft from New England for its 2004 second-rounder, then selected offensive lineman Wade Smith. Smith gave the Dolphins limited early-career value before becoming a better player elsewhere. New England’s future pick became No. 56 and was traded to Cincinnati for Corey Dillon. Dillon immediately rushed for a franchise-record season and helped the Patriots win Super Bowl XXXIX, creating an overwhelming New England advantage.
Miami Dolphins Received
- pick 2003 3rd round pick (78th overall, Wade Smith )
New England Patriots Received
- pick 2004 2nd round pick (56th overall; traded to Cincinnati for Corey Dillon)
Trade Analysis
Why the Trade Happened
Miami wanted an additional 2003 selection and targeted offensive line help, while New England was willing to defer value into the following draft. The Dolphins received pick No. 78 and selected Wade Smith. In exchange, the Patriots obtained Miami’s second-round choice in 2004, which landed at No. 56.
What Miami Received
Smith appeared for Miami as a young offensive lineman but never established himself there as the long-term answer the Dolphins hoped to find. He later built a much stronger NFL career with other clubs, including Houston, but trade evaluation has to focus on the value delivered to the acquiring team. Miami’s return was therefore limited.
How New England Turned the Future Pick Into a Star
The Patriots never used No. 56 on a rookie. Before the 2004 draft, they traded that choice to Cincinnati for veteran running back Corey Dillon. Dillon responded with a massive first season in New England, rushing for more than 1,600 yards and giving the offense a powerful element it had lacked. He then contributed throughout the postseason as the Patriots won Super Bowl XXXIX.
Why This Trade Still Matters
The transaction is a textbook example of the strategic value of future picks. New England accepted delayed compensation, then used that asset to acquire an established veteran at the right moment for a championship roster. Miami received a player who did not provide comparable value during his Dolphins tenure.
Final Verdict
New England Patriots Win. The Patriots earn an A because the acquired future second became the price for a championship-caliber season from Dillon. Miami earns a C- because Smith’s later career cannot erase the limited return the Dolphins received themselves.