NFL Trade Verdict

Baltimore Ravens Win

Summary: Jacksonville traded the 86th pick (Marshal Yanda) to Baltimore and received three picks: Adam Podlesh (101st, punter), Derek Landri (166th), and a 6th-round pick. Analysis: On the surface, moving down for extra picks looks fine. In reality, this is one of Jacksonville's costliest undervaluation mistakes. Marshal Yanda became arguably the best offensive guard of his generation — a 9-time Pro Bowler who played at an All-Pro level for 13 seasons. Jacksonville got a punter and two fringe players. This was not a C+ trade; it was a quiet catastrophe in hindsight. Grade revised to D+. Because Yanda became a Hall-of-Fame-caliber guard, this belongs among the franchise's major missed-value trades.

April 28, 2007 Jacksonville JaguarsBaltimore Ravens Confidence: high Tier: major

Jacksonville Jaguars Received

Baltimore Ravens Received

Trade Summary

Summary: Jacksonville traded the 86th pick (Marshal Yanda) to Baltimore and received three picks: Adam Podlesh (101st, punter), Derek Landri (166th), and a 6th-round pick. Analysis: On the surface, moving down for extra picks looks fine. In reality, this is one of Jacksonville's costliest undervaluation mistakes. Marshal Yanda became arguably the best offensive guard of his generation — a 9-time Pro Bowler who played at an All-Pro level for 13 seasons. Jacksonville got a punter and two fringe players. This was not a C+ trade; it was a quiet catastrophe in hindsight. Grade revised to D+. Because Yanda became a Hall-of-Fame-caliber guard, this belongs among the franchise's major missed-value trades.

Trade Analysis

Summary: Jacksonville traded the 86th pick (Marshal Yanda) to Baltimore and received three picks: Adam Podlesh (101st, punter), Derek Landri (166th), and a 6th-round pick. Analysis: On the surface, moving down for extra picks looks fine. In reality, this is one of Jacksonville's costliest undervaluation mistakes. Marshal Yanda became arguably the best offensive guard of his generation — a 9-time Pro Bowler who played at an All-Pro level for 13 seasons. Jacksonville got a punter and two fringe players. This was not a C+ trade; it was a quiet catastrophe in hindsight. Grade revised to D+. Because Yanda became a Hall-of-Fame-caliber guard, this belongs among the franchise's major missed-value trades. Baltimore moved up 15 spots in Round 3 to take Yanda, paying an extra 5th and 6th. The return was one of the greatest draft steals at the position in NFL history. Grade: A+ Baltimore turned the move into Marshal Yanda, one of the defining offensive linemen of his generation.