New England and Baltimore swapped four selections during the…

The Exchange

New England and Baltimore completed a four-pick exchange during the 2009 NFL Draft. The Patriots received fourth-round No. 123 and sixth-round No. 198, which became Rich Ohrnberger and Jake Ingram. Baltimore received fifth-round Nos. 137 and 141, with No. 137 becoming Jason Phillips. The later history of No. 141 should be kept separate from the direct exchange rather than treated as an extra Ravens asset. New England Patriots Return New England moved into the fourth round for Ohrnberger and also acquired the sixth-round choice used on Ingram. Ohrnberger provided interior-line depth, while Ingram handled long-snapping duties for a period. Those are legitimate roster outcomes, but neither player became a long-term cornerstone or generated enough surplus value to make the Patriots' two-pick return clearly superior. Baltimore Ravens Return Baltimore accepted two fifth-round selections. Jason Phillips offered linebacker depth, and No. 141 gave the Ravens another mid-round asset to work with. The package was sensible because it kept two selections in a similar portion of the draft rather than concentrating value in one player. Still, the realized Baltimore outcomes did not produce a durable star or a clear advantage over New England's return. Value in Hindsight The trade remained what it looked like on draft day: a modest reshuffling of middle- and late-round opportunities. New England received one slightly earlier pick plus a later selection, while Baltimore received two choices clustered in the fifth round. None of the players tied directly to the exchange generated enough long-term team value to create meaningful separation. Final Verdict New England and Baltimore each receive a C. Both clubs extracted some roster utility, but neither side landed the kind of player who would turn this pick swap into a clear win. The fairest result is an Even Trade.