NFL Trade Verdict

Green Bay Packers Win

Cleveland acquired Bobby Garrett; Roger Zatkoff from Green Bay Packers for Vito Parilli / Babe Parilli; John Petitbon; Billy Kinard; Sam Palumbo; John Macelli / John Macerelli; Carlton Massey. The available record points to a balanced exchange or low-stakes roster churn, not a clear historical win.

April 19, 1957 Cleveland Browns ↔ Green Bay Packers Confidence: high Tier: minor

Cleveland Browns Received

player Bobby Garrett
player Roger Zatkoff

Green Bay Packers Received

player Vito Parilli / Babe Parilli
player John Petitbon
player Billy Kinard
player Sam Palumbo
player John Macelli / John Macerelli
player Carlton Massey

Cleveland Browns

C+

Green Bay Packers

B+

Trade Analysis

Green Bay Packers received Vito Parilli / Babe Parilli; John Petitbon; Billy Kinard; Sam Palumbo; John Macelli / John Macerelli; Carlton Massey and gave up Bobby Garrett; Roger Zatkoff.