NFL Trade Verdict

The Raiders acquired three-time Pro Bowl tackle Brian…

The Raiders acquired three-time Pro Bowl tackle Brian Holloway from New England in 1987 for three identified draft choices: a 1988 fifth, a 1988 tenth and a 1989 seventh. Holloway played 14 games with eight starts for the Raiders over 1987-88. New England gained multiple selections, but none of the players tied to those picks became a major NFL difference-maker. The balanced short-term-versus-volume return supports an even verdict.

New England Patriots Received

  • pick 1988 fifth round pick (#115-Troy Wolkow)
  • pick 1988 tenth round pick (#267-Rodney Lossow)
  • pick 1989 seventh round pick (#178-Eric Lindstrom)

Trade Analysis

The Exchange

In September 1987, the Raiders acquired veteran offensive tackle Brian Holloway from New England. The Patriots' return was three draft choices: a fifth-rounder and a tenth-rounder in 1988 plus a seventh-rounder in 1989. Those selections are identifiable as the choices associated with Troy Wolkow, Rodney Lossow and Eric Lindstrom. The package therefore involved real multi-pick compensation rather than an undefined future asset.

Los Angeles Raiders Return

Holloway arrived with an accomplished résumé that included three Pro Bowl selections in New England. He was no longer at his peak, but he still gave the Raiders immediate offensive-line help. Raiders history credits him with 14 games and eight starts across 1987 and 1988. That is meaningful short-term use from a veteran acquisition, particularly because the team was buying established experience rather than developmental upside.

New England Patriots Return

New England chose draft volume and future flexibility. A fifth-round selection carried the most meaningful value, with the tenth- and seventh-rounders adding two more opportunities. None of the players associated with those picks developed into a major long-term NFL contributor, which prevents the Patriots from turning the three-pick package into an obvious win.

Value in Hindsight

The shape of the trade is balanced. Los Angeles received a proven lineman for two seasons and eight starts, while New England received three selections but no standout downstream player. Holloway's brief tenure limits the Raiders' grade, and the modest results from the picks limit the Patriots' grade.

Final Verdict

This is an Even Trade at B-/B-. Both clubs obtained something useful without producing a lasting franchise-changing result. The Raiders bought competent veteran work, and New England replenished draft capital; neither side generated enough surplus value to separate clearly.

Sources