NFL Trade Verdict
New York Giants Win
Washington received Clifton McNeil from New York Giants for 1972 fifth round pick (probably #121-Larry Edwards), 1972 sixth round pick (later replaced with Richmond Flowers because Redskins did not have a 1972 sixth round pick) and 1972 seventh round pick (probably #177-Mike Zikas). The recorded outcome favors New York Giants.
New York Giants Received
- pick 1972 fifth round pick (probably #121-Larry Edwards)
- pick 1972 sixth round pick (later replaced with Richmond Flowers because Redskins did not have a 1972 sixth round pick)
- pick 1972 seventh round pick (probably #177-Mike Zikas)
Washington Commanders Received
- player Clifton McNeil
Trade Analysis
New York Giants received 1972 fifth round pick (probably #121-Larry Edwards), 1972 sixth round pick (later replaced with Richmond Flowers because Redskins did not have a 1972 sixth round pick) and 1972 seventh round pick (probably #177-Mike Zikas), while Washington received Clifton McNeil. The recorded results support the existing B/D+ grades and New York Giants Win verdict.