NFL Trade Verdict

Green Bay Packers Win

Green Bay acquired Dick Nolan from Arizona/St. Louis Cardinals for draft pick (undisclosed pick). The Packers side produced stronger hindsight value, either through the better player outcome, better draft conversion, or a superior capital return. Green Bay gets the higher grade because the retained value and on-field return outweighed the cost.

August 30, 1959 Arizona CardinalsGreen Bay Packers Confidence: medium Tier: minor

Arizona Cardinals Received

  • pick draft pick (?-?)

Trade Analysis

Arizona/St. Louis Cardinals received draft pick (undisclosed pick) and gave up Dick Nolan. Green Bay Packers receives the edge because the recorded return carries stronger long-term football value than the package credited to Arizona Cardinals.