Houston sent the 134th pick in the 2006 draft to Buffalo for…
Houston sent the 134th pick in the 2006 draft to Buffalo for veteran receiver Eric Moulds. Moulds gave the Texans one season, catching 57 passes for 557 yards and a touchdown. Buffalo used No. 134 on defensive tackle Kyle Williams, who spent 13 seasons with the Bills and reached six Pro Bowls. That enormous difference in longevity and impact makes Buffalo the clear winner.
Buffalo Bills Received
- pick 2006 5th round pick (134th overall, Kyle Williams)
Houston Texans Received
- player Eric Moulds
Trade Analysis
Why the Trade Happened
Houston entered 2006 looking for an established receiver to complement Andre Johnson and acquired Eric Moulds from Buffalo for the 134th overall selection. Moulds had been a three-time Pro Bowler with the Bills and brought immediate experience to a young Texans offense. Buffalo, meanwhile, accepted a fifth-round choice for a veteran who was moving on after a decade with the franchise.
What Houston Received
Moulds started 15 games for Houston in 2006 and caught 57 passes for 557 yards with one touchdown. He provided the veteran presence the Texans sought, but the arrangement lasted only one season. Houston released him the following offseason, so the return never developed into the multi-year receiving partnership the club hoped to create alongside Johnson.
What Buffalo Received
The Bills used the 134th pick on defensive tackle Kyle Williams. He became a starter early in his career and remained with Buffalo for 13 seasons. Williams eventually reached six Pro Bowls and became one of the organization's most respected long-term players. A fifth-round selection turning into that level of sustained production represents exceptional value, especially when the outgoing veteran contributed only briefly for the acquiring club.
Why the Verdict Lands Here
Houston's logic made sense at the time because Moulds was an accomplished receiver and the price was a fifth-round pick. Hindsight changes the evaluation completely. Buffalo did not merely acquire a future selection; it selected a franchise cornerstone who outlasted Moulds' Houston tenure by more than a decade.
Final Verdict
Buffalo Bills Win. Buffalo earns an A- for converting a fifth-round pick into Kyle Williams, while Houston receives a D because Moulds supplied only one modest season before departing.